Tuesday, January 27, 2009
Jan 27 - Is Phoebe real?
Given that Holden is an unreliable narrator, do you think that there is a chance that Phoebe is a figment of his imagination? What if she is only real in his mind? Think about the situations in which she appears in the novel and the conversations they have...what do you think???
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I think phoebe is real due to the fact that he simply got money from her.i mean where could he get it from? while i could believe that she could be fake from how it mentions how he talks to ali and all whenn he is depressed. He never mentions this with talking to pheobe though. he seems to be happier when talking to her aswell. He bought the cd for pheobe and als took her on the carosail(sp?). Holden also goes to school and writes a note for her. I guess it is just hard for me to think that he could totally make up a whole person from what he does with her and how he interacts with others. Holden also mentioned trying to call her up so i think the evidence supports that she is real.
ReplyDeleteI think it is possible that Holden imagined Phoebe because he makes up so many other things in the book. It's possible that Phoebe is made up also. She could be an imaginary little sister that he created so he would feel like there was someone that he could trust. When Holden is talking about doing things with Phoebe they could be what he thinks he would do with a little sister if he had one.
ReplyDeleteI believe that Phoebe was not a character of Holden's imagination. I am open to the idea that she might have been, but I severely doubt it. He received and gave physical items to Phoebe. He could not have imagined a physical item and used it. He also goes to the office of her school to give her a note and the secretary doesn't deny there being a Phoebe. Granted, he is always happier talking to and about her, so she might have been in his head fo his own benefit. Given all of the other evidence, I think Phoebe was existant.
ReplyDeleteI really doubt Phoebe was a figment of Holden's imagination. We know that Holden is an unreliable narrator, but I don't think he was at a point in his mental breakdown where he would create a whole other person in his mind. I actually think Phoebe was the one thing that kept Holden from going crazy. We notice that he is cynical and pessimistic whenever he talks about others, but he rarely does that with Phoebe. Much like Jeannine's relationship with Conrad in Ordinary People, I think Phoebe gave Holden a feeling of being needed. He felt that she could not live without him around. If Holden hadn't had his sister in his life, I think his mental and emotional problems would have been much more serious.
ReplyDeleteAlthough I think that Phoebe is in all likelyhood real, there is a chance that Holden could be imagining her. The only reason I think that is because she is so similar to Allie. She's smart. She's a writer. She has red hair. These are all characteristics shared with Allie. Holden could have created Phoebe in his mind as a way to replace the brother he lost. Even so, I am still pretty certain that Phoebe is real. There is too much in the plot that revolves around Holden's reaction with her.
ReplyDeleteI think shes real because he gots money from her and went to her school.
ReplyDeleteI personally think that Phoebe was a real character and not a figment of Holden's imagination. Holden never mentions Phoebe being with him, unless he was near or at home. If he was just imagining her he probably would have acted as if she was with him through out most of the novel. He talks about her mostly towards the end. Which is when he is near home since Phoebe is his little sister that is where she lives. Phoebe also gives Holden her Christmas money that she had been saving, and he uses it to pay for taxi rides, and other things. He also goes to her school to give her a note, telling her that he will be leaving. Even though it is possible that Phoebe might be a figment of imagination. I just highly doubt it because if Phoebe was not real then a lot of the story towards the end would also have been made up. Like other people have said i don't think Holden's mental conditions were that serious to have made up such a big part of his life and the novel.
ReplyDeleteJordan
In this book, anything is possible. Like Mrs. Stallman told our group (group 2) a few days ago, the entire story could have been made up from Holden's mind because of how messed up he really is. There is a large possibility that Phoebe could be fictional. There's also a large possibility that Phoebe could be as real as the air we breathe. (Well, in the fictional world the story takes place in...) I honestly believe Phoebe is real, because the story is written that way. The story would be a lot more interesting if we found out that she wasn't real, however. She could have been a hallucination that represented Holden's conscience, or something along those lines.
ReplyDeleteThere is no actual proof of Phoebe's reality. All of the instances where she is present in the book could have been made up in Holden's mind, from her giving him money to her giving Holden's hat back and him watching her ride the carousel. A proof that she might not exist is when they were sitting in her room and Holden kept telling her to quiet down because she would wake up their parents. However, she never got quieter and never woke up their parents. This could mean her voice never existed, so no one else heard it. Summary: I believe Phoebe is real. Although there's substantial proof that she isn't, its still in the story, so therefore, I'm going to believe that it happened.
I really doubt Phoebe could be imagined. It would be very difficult to imagine the money he gave her, as well as his visit her in her room. I accept the possibility, but if Holden lied about Phoebe, I'm inclined to believe most of the book was lies.
ReplyDeleteAlso, I love your reasoning Nathan. Nice and thorough.
I think Phoebe is real. There is the fact that he goes into his house and seems to stay there for a while talking to her. he may have exagerated the length of time he spent with her, and what he says they talked about may never have happened. I beleive that he definitely has a sister named Phoebe, however, A person can't just make that up. He even claims to have gotten money from her, although he may have stole that from his parents while he was there. I think Phoebe is real and that there is aconnection between her and Holden. This may be one of the few times that he is actually a source of reliable information
ReplyDeleteI also believe Phoebe is real. The way Holden describes her throughout the book is very obsessive, true, but that could just mean he truly cares for her. I could see how he could just be imagining everything, though.
ReplyDeleteI have to agree with Kurt, what Nathan wrote was truly marvelous!
I would have to say that I agree with Grayson. Phoebe had to be real because Holden ran out of money and borrowed some from her. If he didn't, how else would he pay for the things he used it on after? Also, while I do agree that Holden was bonkers, I don't think that he was so crazy that he could completely make up a person in his mind. She also seemed way too important in his life to be fake. He even had memories of her when he was younger, which I imagine would be tough to completely make up about a person who isn't even real.
ReplyDeleteI think Phoebe is a real character. Even if holden is crazy i still think holden actually visits her and has a real conversation. Also, Phoebe gives holden money and i'm pretty sure you can not spend money if it is not there. I think she is real because he buys the record for her and always talks about her and how great she is. I don't think he would make that up from the begining. He also cares a lot about Phoebe. I think Phoebe is real, Holden is not that creative even if he is crazy.
ReplyDeleteI also think that Phoebe is real. There is plenty of evidence in the story to support that she is not just part of Holden’s imagination. Although, I might just think that she is real because I easily believe what people tell me :-D
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI think that Phoebe is very real, in the sense that she is real "in spirit", or in Holden's conscience. Now, as to if she is real "in the flesh", this could be difficult to prove. I think it depends on the reader's interpretation of how 'mentally unstable' Holden really is. If Holden is seen as slightly unstable to some people, then Phoebe could be an actual flesh and blood person. However, if a person were to view Holden as psychotic and totally screwed up in the head, then Phoebe could possibly be a figment of his imagination. As seen in the novel many times, Holden "talks" with Allie, even though the reader knows that Allie is dead. Now, I have come up with the hypothesis that he took the qualities of Allie, and "pictured" his "sister", who could then, in turn, be imaginary. Although, Phoebe does give him money, which he eventually keeps. However, one could argue that he REALLY robbed a bank, or committed some other crime in order to get the money. In my mind, Holden is mentally torn up, but if he can believe that fictional figment’s are real, then who knows what he really could have experienced. Because, as we all, know, he lies AND he's in a mental institution sharing his story in a flashback. Sometimes, as in the case with Mr. Antolini, he misinterprets an event. Misinterpretation can lead from one thing to another, and he really could be drunk in his hotel room, daydreaming the whole interaction up. There are thoughts in my head that tell me that, in reality, Holden learned the moral of the novel by himself. Which, in turn, could possibly mean that Phoebe, the bedroom interaction, the Carousel...none of it could have REALLY happened. There is evidence that DOES state, however, that it DID occur. Although Holden is distant from his parents, I don't think it's likely that his mother somehow MAGICALLY became pregnant and had a baby girl without Holden knowing. Besides the fact, Phoebe was alive when Allie died. So, there are supporting and degrating facts that support the thesis. My thoughts are split, and can easily sway from one side to the other. There is no definite answer, in my mind. To me, it all depends on interpretation.
ReplyDeleteI really dont know what i believe. I never thought of Phoebe being imagined but it would make sense. Holden made up and exagerated a lot and him making up a person is possible. Holden never connected or let anyone in so for him to have someone who in his eyes completely gets him is odd. He could have imagined her to heal the loss of Allie, like a another younger sibling to take his place. Phoebe could easilu just be a figment of Holdens imagination. To the evidence of money, Holden could have simply broken into his house and stolen the money from his parents, and just imagined Phoebe giving it to him.
ReplyDeleteI believe Phoebe also could be a real person. I believe this just because some on the conversations they have i dont think Holden would say to himself. Like how Phoebe calls Holden out about schools and Allie. Also because i think Holden sends her a letter to her school telling her to meet him. He also has a lot of encounters with her like giving her the record.
I really dont know, this is such a strange book with one perspective. The whole entire story could be made up, Holden is a very unreliable character.
I believe that Phoebe is real. If you think about it how was he able to get the money and some of the conversations they had were of real things. With the record and the very end with the carousel and him writing her the letter.
ReplyDeleteBut then again she could be in his imagination. He imagines Allie all the time and talks to him like he is really there. So you could never really know. Like Jessica said it is a really strange book.
Katie W
There are several point in the story that I believe point to Phoebe being a real character such as the money and the hat, Holden's mother coming and talking to Phoebe etc. However I also believe that Phoebe could just be in Holden's imagination because she is really the only character in the book that could influence Holden enough to change his mind and really the only person that could make him happy, a person he did not automatically find fault with and criticize.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI personally consider the concept of Phoebe being a construct of Holden's imagination ridiculous. Throughout the story, he preforms actions which would not make any logical sense if Phoebe was imaginary. One of these events is his epiphany while she is riding the Carousel. Would this have occurred with a figment of his imagination, designed to reinforce his view on the world? This concept is ridiculous, as why would he deliberately destroy his own perspective on things?
ReplyDeleteLol okay Mrs. Stallman, yeah I'd say that made me think. But yes, I think phoebe is real. Holden is an unreliable narrator, yes, and he was in a mental hospital, but still I think she is real. I think Danny made a really good point. While Holden could have thought up or imagined the Christmas money, even spending the Christmas money (and theoretically but probably not everything else in the story) I really don't believe he would subconsciously go all that way to make up memories of her too. You can't imagine someone who's not really there your whole life. Well, you can if you're really messed up. But like I said, I don't think Holden would go all that way. But then again, how did he realize he needed to go to a mental hospital? While he was in the city, he didn't really do anything absolutely "crazy" like Conrad did, he did get drunk and stuff but I don't know if that along with being depressed was grounds for sending him to a mental hospital. Wouldn't they just send him to a counselor? Maybe he did make it all up and was delusional or something, maybe we were just hearing his imagination. someone we didn't hear about could have noticed this and eventually put him in the hospital. Or, I'm just over thinking this. But I still think Phoebe is real.
ReplyDeleteSeeing as everyone elses comments are so huge im going to add on to my response. If phoebe wasnt real then neither was the Christmas dough, or the taxi he payed for with the Christmas dough, or the school, and a lot of other things. It was an interesting question but I'm still pretty certain that in the book phoebe was real or Holden would have to have really been messed up.
ReplyDeleteWell, thanks for the confidence-boosting comment that this was a ridiculous question, Sean! Actually, it needs to be taken seriously...and needs to be contemplated in a "think outside the box" sort of way. Has anyone viewed the film A Beautiful Mind? (Pretend that title was underlined!) Based on a true story, a highly intelligent man struggled with a mental disease that led him to hallucinate very real (to him) people. Also, consider what Noah suggested about the fact that Holden never found fault with Phoebe - the ONLY character in which he found to be flawless. She seem to epitomize all the qualities that he found to be genuine and found to be lacking in the "adult" world...and yet she was a child. Interesting...futhermore, she was a very mature, level-headed child, seemingly left alone quite a bit, who tended to only speak to Holden at times when no one else was around...anyways...just an interesting theory I though I would throw out for contemplation...or laughter (in Sean's case...)
ReplyDeleteI think that Phoebe is real. I mean he got Christmas money from her, he went to her school, and when he visited Phoebe his mother came in to say goodnight to her. Plus as someone said in class he's telling the story from when he's getting released so I hope he's not still making things up, at least not people. Then they might want to reconsider the whole release. But he's is still in a mental hospital and there is a chance that he made her up from his imagination. You have a point saying that she's someone that he wants himself to be, there's nothing wrong with her in his eyes. You could look at that as either he made her up as someone he could try to be or as his actual sister whom he loves and always has. He's already lost a brother why not cherish his sister especially since she's so young and he seems to really like children.
ReplyDelete