Friday, May 1, 2009

May 1 - Thoreau

"Unjust laws exist; shall we be content to obey them, or shall we endeavor to amend them, and obey them until we have succeeded, or shall we transgress them at once?" Discuss this quote of Thoreau's general terms and in relation to the novel.

21 comments:

  1. Thoreau is asking "Will we be content with laws, or will we try to fix them, but abide by them until we succeed in fixing? Or, will we override the laws at once?" In relation to 1984, Winston chooses the second question: "Will we try to fix them, but abide by them until we succed in fixing?". However, Winston is really NOT changing them by speaking against the government. Thoreau would argue that Winston is really not changing anything, but he is waiting for others (Brotherhood, proles, etc.) to change things for him. The same holds true for Julia, as well as all of the other rebels in Oceania. None of them seem to have taken any true drastic action against Big Brother.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thoreau is further describing how laws can bypass moral boundaries. Some laws may interfere with individual's belief's and self-held truths. He goes on to explain the ways in which we can deal with these laws: obey them, amend or change them until they fit perfectly, or completely disobey and disregard them instantaneously. In terms of the novel, Winston feels as though his natural rights have been violated by the Party's laws, one of the major ones being his right to intercourse with his partner Julia. His path to dealing with the laws, however, is silent and unhelpful protest of simply sleeping with Julia whenever he had the chance. This is not an adequate form of protest (according to Thoreau and Mrs. Stallman (I think you'll find it interesting that I just added your last name to my dictionary)), but it could fall under the category of simply transgressing the laws. Note they aren't doing it in public as to arouse any public interest in changing said laws, but they are still, however, breaking them. By breaking the laws they are morally freeing themselves to do what they feel is naturally right, however illegal or corrupt the actions are.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I believe Thoreau is saying that when you are unhappy with a law or rule you have the choice to follow it and be miserable or to act against it. Thoreau is saying that you can work to change or "ammend" that unjust law.Thoreau also says when the unjust rule is in effect you can either choose to follow it until it changes or you can rebel against it completely with or without trying to change it. This relates to the novel because Winston is faced with both of these choices. Winston detests almost all of the laws/rules of the party. Winston passively refuses to follow the laws by ingaging in sex crime and thought crime, poor protests according to Thoreau. Winston doesn't really work to change the laws, but later on he does take the step of joining the "brotherhood". According to Threau this would be a more effective step to ammend the unjust laws, but not exactly going to the root of the problem.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thoreau is asking, "Laws that are morally wrong exist, so shall we deal with them or shall we try to change them for the better? And in the process, should we wait to disobey the original law until it is changed, or should we disobey the original law before it is changed?" In the novel, Winston casually disobeys the laws he doesn't agree with. This method is not something Thoreau would agree with because it is too passive, it's not taking action. Thoreau would say that Winston is not being agrresive enough in his want to change society. That is also true, Winston, Julia and the Brotherhood really haven't done anything yet to take down Big Brother, they have just quitely rebelled in their own private lives. In response to Thoreau's question, Winston's actions don't entirely say he will be content with the laws, but they also don't entirely say he will endeavor to amend them either.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Our good friend Mr. Thoreau is begging the question, 'How do we most effectively change unjust laws?' He claims that either we can sit back and abide by them, attempt to change them but continue to follow them until changed (like in a democracy), or throw the law out the window and not care what the law enforcers say. In 1984, Winston is taking the first path I mentioned. He wants to change things, but all he does is sit and wait for others to start a rebellion. Henry would probably not be very happy with Winny.

    Pwr 2 the l33t, peace b 2 the nublets.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thoreau is stating that there are basically three options of action to confront unjust laws. The first would be to do nothing; the second would be to try to change them but to obey them until any change is made; the third would be to break all of the unjust laws. This relates to 1984 because at first Winston goes along with all the unjust laws of Big Brother. Throughout the novel, Winston starts to change his actions and wishes that he could amend the laws but makes no real accomplishments that would cause them to be changed. Winston later makes the decision to start breaking all of the unjust rules of Big Brother.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thoreau is say that there are laws that people don't agree with. He says should we obey them even though we don't agree with them. And maybe one day things will change. Or should we do somthing to try to change them. This relates to the novel because there are a lot of people in the party that don't agree with the rules. But there is no one out there trying to change them. Winston secretly disobeys the laws but really does nothing to try to change them.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Unjust laws do exist. Should one just sit back and complain about it but never attempt to fix the problem? If one has a problem with the unjust law, they should have the right to protest and ammend the law. In the navel, it is unjust that there is Thought Crime. One should be able to think for themselves. Those in 1984 realized this, they did covert operations to change the law.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thoreau is saying that there are always going to be laws that we don't agree with. He is saying that we can either deal with them or try to change them. Also, we can either try to change them by obeying them while trying to change them or disobey them. This is like in the civil rights movement of the 1950s. Some people just took the pain of discrimination. Some, such an Martin Luther King, Jr. obeyed the laws while vying for equality. Some groups, such as the Black Panthers, took drastic action. In relation to the novel, Julia and Winston sit somewhere between the second and third category. They do break the laws, but on the surface they try hard to follow what the party says and appear orthodox.

    ReplyDelete
  10. _____Thoreau is wondering what we should do if we disagree with laws we believe to be unjust instated by the government. He says we can just follow them, follow them with the intention of amending them, or "transgress them at once." In 1984, Winston and Julia pretend to follow the laws and appear orthodox, but they do not agree with them. They have the intention of helping the brotherhood to destroy the party and its practices the whole time they are appearing content and orthodox.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thoreau is saying that we can either obey laws we believe are unjust or we can change them. If we decide to change them, we can try to fix them and obey them until they are fixed, or we can fix them immediately. In 1984, Winston obeyed the Party's laws at first even though he disagreed with them. Then he met Julia and they disobeyed the laws even though they still pretended to support them. Although they didn't actively do anything to change the law, they weren't obeying it either.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thorough asks the readers if they are going to sit around and let people make unfair laws for them. He wants to know if people will take action against these laws. He would rather we didn't obey them at all rather than obey them until they get fixed. In 1984 Winston and Julia don't obey very many of the Party's rules. They don't agree with them, so they take Thorough's advice and break the laws at once. In the end, they are arrested for their trouble. They didn't sit back and obey unfair laws, though

    ReplyDelete
  13. (Nice spelling of "Thorough" Kevin :D)

    Thoreau is making the point that laws can be corrupt. In the presence of these laws, Thoreau asks, what is it that we do? Do we sit back idly as these corrupt laws govern our lives? Doe we follow these corrupt laws, even in our knowledge in them? Do we even know of these laws and their corruption?

    In 1984, there are no relative freedoms to speak of. However, there are also no laws. Anyone can do whatever they want, and nothing can be held against them. Not in context of laws, anyway. The Party convicts those who go against their tenets (for lack of a better term) in mind, and thus action. Their ultimatum harbors a society of people (if they can be called people) who bare no thoughts of their own. No thoughts means no actions - and with no actions there is no need for laws.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Thoreau is stating that there are some laws we don't agree with and out of those laws we have the ability to change some. We shouldn't sit around with laws that confine us from doing what we think is right. We should take a chance and change what we feel is wrong. In 1984 Winston and Julia go against the anti sex laws and do what they feel is right. Winston also starts to take a chance in getting rid of Big Brother. He joins O'Brien in the secret society and goes against Big Brother.

    ReplyDelete
  15. thoreau here is basically asking if a government comes up with laws that the people don't agree with, what should the people do about it? we could obey them or try to amend them. This relates to the novel because Winston and Julia do not like the laws that were put into place by big brother, so rather than obeying them, they do their best to amend them. The way they go about doing that though is by breaking as many as they can and rebelling any way they can.

    Oh, and I found a fun historical quote. "Things are more like they are now than they have ever been." -Gerald Ford. Aparently, that was important enough that our history book needed us to remember it.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thoreau is asking what we should do about unjust laws. Often times people might hate the laws but do nothing about them. Some people just ignore laws they think are unfair. I think instead Thoreau would want people to try to fix these unjust laws. In 1986 Winston and Julia wished to amend them but didn't know how and instead just transgressed them. Eventually they hoped to try to amend them but so far they haven't done anything productive. This quote from Thoreau relates to Civil Disobedience and trying to amend unjust situations.

    and danny don't be diss'n jerry

    ~Nathan

    ReplyDelete
  17. What Thoreau is saying in this quote is that in this world, there are laws that don't really make sense and are we happy enough in our lives that we should just go along with them? or should we take action against them because they don't make sense? If you are happy enough in your life, go on living it with that unjust law. But if you are unhappy and feel that the law needs to be changed, try to change it as soon as you can. This relates to the book because most of the people just go along with all the new laws that big brother puts out and they dont seem to care at all. Then there are other people like winston and julia who need to go against it because they know what's really going on and they feel that they need to stop it.

    ReplyDelete
  18. This means that not all laws are fair, the questions is shall we just obey them, or should we oppose them? If you choose to oppose them, should you attack it at once or just let someone else do it for you? For example, in class Mrs. Stallman brought up the whole lockers debate, have we really tried to get rid of locks or have we just let someone try to do it for us? I still believe we don't really have much of a choice in that example, but it's a choice nonetheless. In the novel, most people are just content to obey the laws, either because they are content enough not to care or for fear if they don't they will be found by the thought police and killed. There are still some that choose to oppose them like Winston and Julia, rather it be by writing in a journal or by sleeping around.

    ReplyDelete
  19. 01010100 01101000 01101001 01110011 00100000 01110001 01110101 01101111 01110100 01100101
    00100000 01101001 01110011 00100000 01110010 01101000 01100101 01110100 01101111 01110010
    01101001 01100011 01100001 01101100 01101100 01111001 00100000 01100001 01110011 01101011
    01101001 01101110 01100111 00100000 01101000 01101111 01110111 00100000 01110100 01101111
    00100000 01100100 01100101 01100001 01101100 00100000 01110111 01101001 01110100 01101000
    00100000 01101100 01100001 01110111 01110011 00100000 01110100 01101000 01100001 01110100
    00100000 01110111 01100101 00100000 01100110 01101001 01101110 01100100 00100000 01110101
    01101110 01101010 01110101 01110011 01110100 00101110 00100000 01001001 01100110 00100000
    01110111 01100101 00100000 01101010 01110101 01110011 01110100 00100000 01101111 01100010
    01100101 01111001 00100000 01110100 01101000 01100101 00100000 01101100 01100001 01110111
    01110011 00101100 00100000 01101110 01101111 01110100 01101000 01101001 01101110 01100111
    00100000 01110111 01101001 01101100 01101100 00100000 01100111 01100101 01110100 00100000
    01100100 01101111 01101110 01100101 00101110 00100000 01001111 01100010 01100101 01111001
    01101001 01101110 01100111 00100000 01110100 01101000 01100101 00100000 01101100 01100001
    01110111 01110011 00100000 01110101 01101110 01110100 01101001 01101100 00100000 01110100
    01101000 01100101 01111001 00100000 01100001 01110010 01100101 00100000 01100001 01101101
    01100101 01101110 01100100 01100101 01100100 00100000 01101001 01110011 00100000 01100001
    00100000 01110011 01101100 01101001 01100111 01101000 01110100 01101100 01111001 00100000
    01100010 01100101 01110100 01110100 01100101 01110010 00100000 01101111 01110000 01110100
    01101001 01101111 01101110 00101100 00100000 01100010 01110101 01110100 00100000 01101001
    01110100 00100000 01101001 01110011 00100000 01110011 01110100 01101001 01101100 01101100
    00100000 01110100 01100001 01101011 01101001 01101110 01100111 00100000 01100001 00100000
    01110000 01100001 01110011 01110011 01101001 01110110 01100101 00100000 01100001 01110000
    01110000 01110010 01101111 01100001 01100011 01101000 00101110 00100000 01010100 01101000
    01100101 00100000 01110100 01101000 01101001 01110010 01100100 00100000 01101111 01110000
    01110100 01101001 01101111 01101110 00100000 01101001 01110011 00100000 01110100 01101111
    00100000 01100100 01100101 01101100 01101001 01100010 01100101 01110010 01100001 01110100
    01100101 01101100 01111001 00100000 01100100 01101001 01110011 01101111 01100010 01100101
    01111001 00100000 01110100 01101000 01100101 00100000 01101100 01100001 01110111 01110011
    00101110 00100000 01010111 01101001 01101110 01110011 01110100 01101111 01101110 00100000
    01100001 01101110 01100100 00100000 01001010 01110101 01101100 01101001 01100001 00100000
    01100011 01101000 01101111 01101111 01110011 01100101 00100000 01110100 01101000 01100101
    00100000 01110100 01101000 01101001 01110010 01100100 00100000 01101111 01110000 01110100
    01101001 01101111 01101110 00101100 00100000 01100010 01110101 01110100 00100000 01100100
    01101111 00100000 01110011 01101111 00100000 01101001 01101110 00100000 01100001 00100000
    01110010 01100001 01110100 01101000 01100101 01110010 00100000 01101001 01101110 01100101
    01100110 01100110 01100101 01100011 01110100 01101001 01110110 01100101 00100000 01101101
    01100001 01101110 01101110 01100101 01110010 00101100 00100000 01100001 01110011 00100000
    01110100 01101000 01100101 01111001 00100000 01100100 01101111 00100000 01101110 01101111
    01110100 00100000 01110011 01110000 01110010 01100101 01100001 01100100 00100000 01110010
    01100101 01100010 01100101 01101100 01101100 01101001 01101111 01101110 00100000 01100001
    01101110 01100100 00100000 01100101 01110110 01100101 01101110 01110100 01110101 01100001
    01101100 01101100 01111001 00100000 01100111 01100101 01110100 00100000 01100011 01100001
    01110101 01100111 01101000 01110100 00101110



    Oops! I wrote it in binary (beat that kurt!) for all of you who aren't computers, here's my post in regular english:
    This quote is rhetorically asking how to deal with laws that we find unjust. If we just obey the laws, nothing will get done. Obeying the laws until they are amended is a slightly better option, but it is still taking a passive approach. The third option is to deliberately disobey the laws. Winston and Julia choose the third option, but do so in a rather ineffective manner, as they do not spread rebellion and eventually get caught.

    ReplyDelete
  20. wow, that was longer than i expected

    ReplyDelete
  21. I believe that Thoreau is discussing the qusteion, shall we be content following the law simply because we are told to, or will we stand up to unjust laws in an attempt to change them. Then Thoreau goes on to discuss shall we make an attempt to change the law but while in the process still obey it, or disobey and always disobey the law. Winston is n the mindset of obeying the law simply because he is told to, or as much because he is in fear of Big Brother and the thought police. Winston is overcome by his hatred of Big Brother and his desire to break the the law to the point where he no longer cares about his own life. That is, until Julia comes and everything changes. Winston begins to break the law, but at work is a mindless drone along with everyone else. Therefore, Winston is "Obeying until he succeeds", or gets caught.

    ReplyDelete