Thursday, April 30, 2009
April 30 - Civil Disobedience
Thoreau wrote an essay called "Civil Disobedience." In it, he wrote "I think that we should be men first, and subjects afterward. It is not desirable to cultivate a respect for the law, so much as for the right. The only obligation which I have a right to assume is to do at any time what I think right. It is truly enough said that a corporation has no conscience; but a corporation of conscientious men is a corporation with a conscience." Discuss your interpretation of this excerpt and its relevance to the novel.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I believe Thoreau is saying that we as people should put our thoughts and morals above that of society or corporation. I think Thoreau is saying we shoould hold our loyalty to ourselves and not to the power that governs us. He is saying that the right of the indivitual thought is higher and more important then the "law". I think he is also saying that by following our own morals we make up a "corporation" that has those same morals. Basically saying that society is made up of its people and follows the beliefs/morals of its people. This relates back to the novel because the party strongly believes that the people make the society. The party wants this feeling of indivitualism to go away. To insure this the party's makes sure all of the people abandon their own thoughts and submit to those of the party. The party ensures that all of the people have the same thoughts as the party therefor making society what the party wants it to be.
ReplyDeleteThoreau is basically saying the that only obligation that a person should have is the obligation to do what is right for themselves as an individual and not for a society. If they do what is right for themselves then the rest will fall into place for the society. If everyone does what is right only for the society, then the society does not have a conscience. But if everyone did what was right for themselvez as an individual, then they would automatically create a society that is conscientious. This relates to the novel because the whole time, the rulerz of the society are trying to get the people to do only what is right for the society, and end up creating only societiez without consciences.
ReplyDeleteGTFY... Mrs. Stallman, ur r the lol
ReplyDeleteThoreau is saying that we should believe what we believe, not what sociery wants us to believe. He says that a society has no conscience unless it is run by men (people) with consciences. In relation to 1984, the government is run by a person who wants to shape history into what he believes to be true. People like Winston and Julia, who have their own consciences, still use them in private. However, they appear to be conscientious to the ideas of Big Brother when they are out in public or when they are in the same room as a telescreen. Thoreau also says "It is not desirable to cultivate a respect for the law, so much as for the right". I believe he says that we shouldn't have to respect the "law", and we shouldn't even be given the right to respect the law. We should believe our own morals and ideas, like the Brotherhood does in the novel.
ReplyDeletep.s. Am I going to be in the Royal Court? Maybe the court Painterer? :)
ReplyDeleteHe wants everyone to have their own views. If a law tells you to do an action you don't agree with, Thoreau tells them to disobey the law. This doesn't work in the real world. If you break the law and are cought, then you get arrested, no matter what is right. in 1984 if you break the law, you are also arrested by the thought police. They tortue you until you don't even know what is right. Then they reteach you the right thing and you have to believe it. They will still shoot you, even if you change your "wrong" ways.
ReplyDeleteI think that Thoreau is saying that it is more important to follow your own conscience than to follow the laws of your government. An individual should be free to form his own opinions. In 1984, this is not the way life is. People are expected to eliminate their own thought and feelings and follow exactly what the government wants them to. I agree with Kevin that unfortunately Thoreau's idea doesn't work in the real world. There has to be some kind of a standard to follow, some set of rules or laws, otherwise bad people would ruin the world. That's the point of democracy. (One of them anyway.) Government for the people, by the people. We elect congressmen who we feel will make laws that reflect our personal conscience. Of course it isn't perfect, especially because there are so many different people with so many different beliefs, but the ability of our government to change is what keeps it alive. In 1984, the government never changes, and certainly not in the direction of the people's consciences. In our government, to correctly represent the many consciences of the many people, new laws are passed. A great example is the civil rights movement. People began to have different ideas about hat was right and what was wrong. They began to follow their consciences, like Thoreau wanted them to, but through civil disobedience and by working with the government, not necessarily against it. Eventually they changed the laws so that they fit more people's moral standards.
ReplyDeleteI believe that Thoreau is discussing how we are to listen to ouselves above all others. Believe in what we believe is right. Not what someone else believes or what you're told to believe, but form your own individual thoughts. Thoreau's line "We should be men first, and subjects afterwards" I believe means that we should listen to the law and obey it, unless it violates our morals or natural rights. Winston and the other members of the party had lost sight of this, following Big Brother and the inner party without question as to whether or not its right.
ReplyDelete-King Beowulf Ruler of The Kingdom of the Arc and Wielder of the Flame Sword
P.S. Join my kingdom, Grayson's is lame. We have parties, and sometimes my mom lets us stay up till 12:00.
Yesss....another fun blog......
ReplyDeleteOne should be himself and a non-conformist before thay are to become a conformist, or subjects. One should not even see desire in conforming but should be independent. It is not even an obligation to do so. One should always do what they think is right and if civil protest and disobedience is one of them, then so be it. This is our obligation to ourselves. One has a conscience is one who thinks in this manner. In 1984, Winston thought in this manner and for the "good of the whole," but never acted on it (civil diseobedience) except for his affair with Julia because there are lews he could break and get taken away for. These laws though, encourage/force people to conform in 1984 as well as our society.
Peace out...joining Noah's kingdom
My brother's playing loud music now, so it's hard to concentrate lol: Thoreau says we should be ourselves before we conform to anyone for any reason. He says nobody will respect the law if it is not right. The only obligation he naturally has from birth is a right to do what is right. So therefore, anyone has a right to do anything, only if it is right. An organization (which can be defined as anything grouped together for a common purpose, a team, a society etc) has no morals,has no respect, knows nothing of the right thing to do, is only in it for the business, the money, the material things. But, if it is made up of moral, respectful,and the "right" people, than the corporation is conscientious and righteous.
ReplyDeleteIf Thoreau read 1984, he would disagree with the whole Party and all of its followers. The reason he would disagree with it is because the outer Party members conform to the Party before they are themselves and are ignorant to the enlightenment idea of natural right. He would say the Party is a corporation with no conscience. He would agree that anyone has the right to overthrow the Party because they are not conscientious, as Throeau would say.
What i think Thoreau is saying is do what YOU think is right no matter what the situation is. He wants us to put our own individual thoughts above everyone else's. Even if it does conflict with the law. The "we should be men first" part is saying to do what you feel and what you believe in. And the "and subjects afterward" is referring to after you do what you believe in then you can deal with the law.
ReplyDeleteDude, Noah, those must be awesome parties if we can sometimes stay up past 11. ha
ReplyDeleteI think Thoreau is saying that we should have our own opinions and ideas and not just go with the crowd. When he says "It is not desirable to cultivate a respect for the law, so much as for the right. The only obligation which I have a right to assume is to do at any time what I think right," he is saying that doing what you think is right is more important that obeying the law, so if what you think is right is not the same as what the law states is right, then it is okay to break the law. When Thoreau is talking about a corporation having a conscience, he is saying that a corporation by itself does not stand for anything, but if you have a corporation of "conscientious men" stands for what those men believe in. In 1984, the society is mostly made up of people who do not have their own opionions, but just follow the crowd. They believe what the party tells them and the party's control over them is what allows their society to exist. If more people thought for themselves and realized that the party was lying to them, like Winston did, then they might be able to overthrow the party.
ReplyDeleteThis kingdom stuff is getting complicated. I think I'm just going to focus on Thoreau this time and keep it simple, I needs to go to bed.
ReplyDeleteI think Thoreau is saying that people should listen to themselves and what they think before they listen to the rest of society and/or the government. Instead of just following the laws people should listen to their own good conscience and feelings of right and wrong. He also says that corporations don't individually have consciences but can be made of conscious people. I'm not sure how else to explain this part, it's already pretty straight forward. In 1986 there are officially no laws but if someone thinks separately from exactly what the party wants them to think then they will probably be vaporized. Rather than listening to their own feelings of right and wrong everyone conforms to the society and the party. A lot of this transcendentalism is anti-conformist which I guess could help people bring out the best in themselves. Of course the party in 1986 hates individualism.
I'm sorry if I have any typos, I've reread this like five times and keep finding new stuff. I'm tired.
in this quote, Thoreau is talking about how not all laws are right, and how what is right may be against he law. He is saying that it is our right and responsibility to disobey the laws when they go against our fundamental beleifs. People also do not act in a concientious manner just because they are in a group, the group acts concientiosly because of the individuals inherent nature.This quote is a ratinalization for winston and julia's behavior, saying they are obligated to oppose the party because it goes against their own moral values
ReplyDeleteI think that Thoreau is trying to say that you are a human before you are part of any society. You have rights as a human, to think your own thoughts and do what you think is right. Sometimes that clashes with what society wants you to do. This is shown in 1984 because Winston has his own thoughts and tries to act on what he believes is right. The government doesn't want him to act the way he does, they want to be able to decide how he acts instead and they want everyone to conform. Thoreau is saying that you should do what you think is right over what society wants you to do, and that's the choice that Winston has chosen, even when knowing the consequences of that choice.
ReplyDeleteThoreau is saying that being an individual is more important than being a part of a community. He thinks that the authority of a leader is only of value if the authority comes with protections of rights and securities. He also says that his only commitment is to himself and to do whatever he thinks would be the best thing to do. This also shows Thoreau's preference on an individual over a society. This relates to 1984 because Winston does not want to obey Big Brother's rules when he thinks doing what he wants is the better thing to do. He wants to destroy Big Brother and break away from the Party. Winston believes his government is not giving people enough freedoms and rights. He thinks that becoming an individual instead of a part of a society is the right thing to do.
ReplyDeleteI think that Thoreau means that we (mankind-ugh i hate that word) should stay true to ourselves before we obey anyone else's rules. He says that, instinctively, humans don't want to obey others' morals above their own. This is kind of the opposite of what is happening in 1984, where the humans have the instinct to obey the party above their own individual thoughts.
ReplyDeleteI know that isn't much, but I'm tired and I don't really understand this quote.
And I want to be part of the court :P
Thoreau is saying that you should put what you think and feel above what the society wants you to. In 1984 they strip you of all your thoughts and feelings and that just isn't right. You have the right to be a human before you are part of any society. Instead of constantly trying to hide your thoughts so you don't get into trouble. Winston doesn't want to obey Big Brother and he thinks these thoughts with the chance of being vaporized. He wants to break away from Big Brother and the society and be his own person.
ReplyDeleteI believe that Thoreau means to say that the individual, ideally, comes before the community. Men should stick to their ideals before going to those of the society. He also states that, despite what the law (more often unjust laws) states, it all comes to the individual to make the right decision. A community of morally conscience individuals just doubles the fact. As for the society by the Party, they believe the opposite. The people should do what the Party insists -- nothing else. No outside thoughts, even. Before any issues can arise, those who cause the issues are eliminated.
ReplyDeleteA certain quote comes to mind:
"Death is the solution to all problems. No man - no problem." - Joseph Stalin
well noah my mom lets us have..................................... sippy cups! yes thats right. haah this kingdom stuff is getting tiring.......... not. We shall be called GRIFFENDORDRRRRRRR
ReplyDeleteGreg is royal painter of my face of grace.
Alex you are now the royal window opener.
What the quote is saying is that you should be your own independent person before you are subjected to any higher power(except in my kingdom where all of you shall bow down... and i will reward you with puppies and jelly beans). He is also saying that the only thing that is required of men is too do what they think is right not what others or the law thinks is right. This quote is basically saying that men should be independent and do what they want to do.
Peace out peeps
wow, grayson you're cool. sippy cups? haaaaa
ReplyDeleteWhat Thoreau or however you spell it is trying to say is that men need to to what's best for them, and put others second. He is saying that every person has a right to believe in and stand for what they are saying. Thoreau is also saying that we have the right to go against the law when we feel that the law is not right or is dumb. This relates to the book because Julia and winston go against the law because they feel that they have the right to do so. They don't think that the law about sex is necessarily needed and so they choose not to abide by it.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThoreau's quote is talking of how that no matter what society thinks is right, you should always base your actions on what you think is right. Society may have laws which contradict your beliefs, as well as what you consider to be right. But you have the power to break, or even change laws that you consider wrong in any way. In 1984, Winston knows that the anti-sex laws are, frankly, just plain stupid, so he decides to simply not abide by them.
ReplyDeleteOhmygod Noah you guys get to stay up till 12?!?!?
I might have to change my affiliation.
Paige:
ReplyDeleteThe "wave" in society is ideas and society in general and how it changes over time. The society in 1984 has a new "wave". When the old wave(the last gereration)crashed, its ideas died with it. The people are not changing just the knowledge of the people. The generation that is left in 1984 that knows the past is the last of the wave but the past to the new generation is foreign. Once the last generations dies that lived before newspeak a new wave will begin.