Monday, April 27, 2009

April 27 - Emerson quote

Emerson says, "Society never advances. It recedes as fast on one side as it gains on the other. It undergoes continual changes; it is barbarous, it is civilized, it is christianized, it is rich, it is scientific; but this change is not amelioration. For everything that is given, something is taken."

Discuss this quote in relation to PART I of the novel, specifically, and also the movie or today's current society. Each post should be a strong paragraph and include a PARTICIPLE (which should be indicated by all caps).

DUE Tuesday morning by 3:00 AM

26 comments:

  1. Part 1 of the book greatly connects to Emerson's quote. The quote is saying that "society never advances" and that for "everything that is given something is taken". The quote is saying soceity never truely advances because with each step foward society looses something. In the book there are tons of technological advances but the freedom is taken away from all the citizens. By WATCHING everyone with the new technology, Big Brother has full control and abuses that power. In the book it is said repeatidly that society and the world is a better place and in some aspects it might be, but the citizens have lost everything therefor making the advances seem like losses. In todays world this concept of society is also true. As our world advances especially in technology out society seems to loose a lot of its old morals. Now that so many gadgets such as computer, ipod, and cell phones are available our world has seen a decrease in family. People aren't as concerned as spending time with family or with keeping up with other morals. Most actions that would be seen as horrible in past are just blown off today and accepted as normal. So as our society advances we too see losses.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The quote basically talkz about how whenever a society gains something benificial, it also loses something beneficial. In the first part of 1984, the society gained so much technology that you would think they could make a perfect society from it. They didn't though, because they instead got a corrupt ruler who took away all of the freedomz of the people. WATCHING, the Big Brother guy can tell what everyone is doing, when they are doing it. And he uses the power of seeing them to make sure that nobody gets a sense of wanting freedom or rebellion.
    In relation to the movie, it is convenient that the pizza place can see whatever they need about a person. It is not so great for that person, however. Sometimes they would not want something to be known by other people. An example would be the book on vacationing cheap that the guy checked out from the library. He would not want everyone to be able to see that he checked out that book. The part that society gains there is the advancement in technology. The down side is that not everyone wants to have their information out in the open like that.

    ReplyDelete
  3. In relation to the novel this quote does seem vailid. When Emerson says "Society never advances. It recedes as fast on one side as it gains on the other." it is holding true to the novel. One such example is the formation of newspeak. Newspeak is made to simplify the current language (considered "old speak" now) and get rid of any negative conitations to the words in the eyes of the rulers. Now while this may seem to be advancing society, really all it is doing is trading in current words for a simple system.This is trading simplicity for word freedom. The man in the video was very flustered with the lady who he was ordering from, OBEYING her pestering he reluctently gave in and ordered the healthy choice. This is limiting his freedoms in society which was traded for the system.

    ReplyDelete
  4. jessica is bad at spelling. i r leet at life and therefore claim myself as king of the classroom... that is all

    ReplyDelete
  5. In this quote, Emerson says that for every advance made, something is taken. In part one of the novel, this is shown by the new language of Newspeak. With the new language, the goal of the party is to reduce the quantity of words so much that the people are unable to relay their thoughts into words. Also so that their are no thoughts of a revolution. This provides control. But what is then taken away is art and feeling and emotion in the language. VIEWED as a benefit to society, conformity is gained by the telescreens. But freedom, peace, and security are taken away. In today's society, the same idea is shown with a lot of technology and electrical products. As soon as you get a new computer, something goes wrong: you may get a virus or it might just be too confusing. That is of course in more simple terms but has the same basic idea.

    ReplyDelete
  6. In order for the society in 1984 to become what it was, some sacrifices were made for what was given (the new society). This supports Emerson's argument. BECOMING a controlling government, Big Brother had to put aside personal liberties of his subjects in order to create their stable society. A second new aspect of the society was that everyone had to conform. In order to do that, the english language was shortened to Newspeak so that rebellious thoughts were limited by that and the Thought Police. Our society has never really "advanced" either. We've accepted an increase in government control whil sacrificing some personal liberties and other such related aspects.

    ReplyDelete
  7. In this quote, Emerson is saying that the balance of power is never equal between two things. In the movie, this would be between the pizza place worker and the customer. As the pizza place worker receives more information about the customer, the balanc of power begins to tip in her favor. In the novel, the balance of power is in favor of the government. They hold all of the cards. DESIRING for more control, "Big Brother" uses surveillance techniques to spy on the residents of Oceania. With this being said, the people then are the unfavorable ones.
    When Emerson says "It undergoes continual changes; it is barbarous, it is civilized, it is christianized, it is rich, it is scientific; but this change is not amelioration", he is listing ajectives about our world that change daily. Most of the time, these changes aren't good, and they require a sacrifice of someting in exchange for this "new world".

    ReplyDelete
  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  9. In this quote, Emerson says that advancements made in society don't come without a cost. GAINING more security is achieved by creating more advanced technology that is used by the the government to spy on the citizens, but with the new technology allows the government to limit people's freedom. People are constantly being monitored and even use speakwrite so that even when people write a note, the government can watch it. Not even people's thoughts are safe. They can be convicted of thoughtcrime for thinking the wrong things. Also, old documents are constantly being changed to make sure that the party is always right. This keeps the party in control, but it gets rid of an accurate record of history.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Part I of 1984 directly relates to Emerson's theories in many ways. For example, Emerson says, "Society never advances", meaning that when society creates a new technology or idea, it also loses something old. Newspeak is an example of this from the novel. Even though Newspeak is a new, advanced language, it erases the beauty of the many languages from the past. ERASING the past, Newspeak is not really as great as the government preaches.
    In relation to the video we watched, the futuristic technology displayed by the pizza place was also an example of how "Society never advances". The new technology was indeed convienent, but by using it, society lost virtually all freedoms. Maybe by using new technologies, we aren't really gaining much; we are only losing pieces of our history.

    ReplyDelete
  11. This quote relates to Part I of 1984 because the ADVANCED society in which the story takes place is not really superior to the society before the revolution. People's freedoms are greatly limited and they lack a sense of privacy. This also relates to the movie's society because the people had limited freedoms to ensure security. In 1984, Citizens have to give up a lot in return for government protection and stability. The 1984 society still has wars, poor people, limited food, and other elements that are not usually associated with a utopian society. In today's society, there is a balance between an individual's rights and privacy and the security of the nation. I think Emerson is saying that taking a step closer to security and stability, is taking a step away from the freedoms of the citizens.

    ReplyDelete
  12. In the novel, there is the advanced part of society and the part that isn't advanced at all from the present. The proles aren't advanced at all. Their society has many similarities to our society today with pubs and makeup and prostitutes. The Party members are more advanced members of society. They have to have telescreens always watching them to make wure they don't go back to the old ways of the proles. Emerson writes that society never advances because it is always receding on one side. 1984 shows his idea with the proles and Party members. Emerson also writes that something is taken away. In the novel, the Party members have an advanced society, but all of their privacy is taken away.

    ReplyDelete
  13. HOPING not to allow the Party members any thoughts of overthrowing the Party, Big Brother takes their privacy.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I think that Emerson is saying that as society progresses, it also takes steps backwards. For every gain there is a CORRESPONDING loss. For instance, in Part I, we can see that the government has gained control, but the people have lost freedom. Also, littler things can follow what Emerson said. The food and drink in Part I has gained better efficiency and lower cost, but it has lost taste. A good example of this in today's society is email. Email has quickened communication and made the earth more community-like, but we have lost the art of letter writing along the way.

    ReplyDelete
  15. The quote relates to the first part of 1984 well. Discussing how in society when you gain something new or innovative there is also something that you you lose. Not everyone realizes what they lose until later on. In the movie as well as both novels, the government and people have created a sort of utopia for themselves, or at least created stability. However, they also gave up their freedoms as well, maybe not even realizing what they gave up till later on. The INSPIRED citizens believing in every word that big brother said, and being thankful they had such a brilliant leader. Emerson writes that "this change is not amelioration", saying that not all change is good change, clearly portrayed in 1984 as well as Brave New World.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Emerson gives the argument that, despite our advancements, we also fall back as a society. RULING with an iron fist, Big Brother controlled every aspect of the Party's life. Winston, too, understood this. This is why he believed the Proles as the only hope, seeing as their freedom was the key to any rebellion against the Party. In 1984's society, freedom was traded for control. The video gives an example of what our society might become - one in which all of everyone's information is free to the public. In that kind of society, as Emerson predicted, a sense of individuality was traded for safety. In concept, that sort of society seems surprisingly close to that of Brave New World, which is an extreme. Does the expanse of our freedoms degrade our morals?

    ReplyDelete
  17. While I think there is some truth to Emerson's quote I don't agree with it completely. For example in the movie they gain the power to prevent murders and they gain convenience but they lose their privacy. In the book I don't think the society gained too much, they seem to actually be poorer than before and they have lost all privacy. Oceania arguably could of gained some stability which is a never ENDING war. In today's society we have many gains that I think outweigh the losses. Electricity for example made life more convenient and comfortable as well as increased worldwide productivity. This may have made people lazier but all technology that makes things more convenient is bound to make people lazier, and is laziness really that bad if your happy anyways? Emerson said that society receded on one side as much as it gained on the other but what does he consider receding? If the ultimate goal of everyone is to be happy and everyone pursues whatever means that make them happy then a happier society had in fact improved over a sad society. Today we have health care, vaccines, drugs, and hospitals. Surely we are happier than Europe during the Middle Ages when the Black Plague killed 1/4 of the population. In history class we are learning about the Vietnam War. In Vietnam the bubonic plague still existed. During the war the U.S. and North and South Vietnam were all miserable. While the U.S. was disappointed to have lost the war the majority of society was overjoyed that the war was finally over. This is an improvement. I think peace keeping organizations like the U.N. are an improvement too. World War I and World War II happened within 30 years of each other. These, along with the Great Depression in between, were some of the most tragic times in our recent history. I think it is due to international organizations such as The U.N. and the International Monetary Fund that we haven't had another World War or large depression. The Cold War couldve easily escalated to a World War but due to advancements in peace talks, diplomacy, and negotiating we haven't all been killed by a nuclear war. Undoubtedly this advancement out weighs any thing else that mightve receded due to it. Something may be taken from society with each of it's advancements but I believe that sometimes the benefit is worth it.

    ReplyDelete
  18. whoa thats long, i really didnt mean to make a long one this time. I'm tired and its like 11:30 and I still need to do my fatal error corrections..

    ReplyDelete
  19. Emerson's statement is like part one in the novel because he says that "society never advances. It recedes as fast on one side as it gains on the other." GAINING technological advances lead to receding freedoms in 1984. For example, the telescreen was invented but with that Big Brother was always watching you, you didn't have the freedom to be alone. In "Minority Report" the advances in society, such as precrime, led to the receding freedom of choice. John didn't have a minority report but even so, he didn't kill the man on purpose, he had the right to choose. The government was going to take that choice away from him and figured it was just destiny, there was no changing it, John proved that to be wrong. Society doesn't advance, you make one move forward just to take another move back. "for everything that is given, something is taken."

    ReplyDelete
  20. Part one of the book is like a magnet for Emerson's quote. He says that society is never balanced, when it moves in one direction it moves away from another. If you want freedom, you have to add risk. If you want stability, you have to sacrifice freedom. A massive amount of security is marred by an almost complete lack of freedom in 1984. When you think a rebellious thought, you can be killed or jailed. If you speak negatively of the Party, you are going to disappear. Big Brother is always watching. LOSING freedom is happening slowly in modern society, with people able to be tracked with credit cards and web ads changing based on what you are buying.

    ReplyDelete
  21. In this quote, Emerson is saying that as one part of our society advances, another part of it doesnt. The part that lacks can at times become more uncivilized. This relates to part one of the book because as new techologies advance, privacy and freedom become less and less. The gain of security and teconological advances in 1984 completely sacrifices the freedom that they used to have. TAKING away privacy and the memories of the old world are just things that need to be sacrificed in order to have a more advanced, civilized world. This quote also relates to the movie because as soon as the man calls the pizza place, the woman answering his call automatically knows everything about him. His privacy about what he has bought and his medical records are taken away from him because of the advancements that the pizza place made in technology. For all steps forward, something needs to be sacrificed

    ReplyDelete
  22. The quote by Emerson is saying that with a gain comes a loss. It relates to Part 1 of 1984 because in the novel they gain a lot of advanced technology. Such as the telescreens. But what the people loose is their freedom. This is because they are constantly being watched. Even in todays society we are LOOSING our freedom. Now the government can listen into our phone conversations and read our text messages. Emerson also mentions how our society goes through continual changes. Advancements in technology is usually what puts our society through continual changes. Such as cars, computers, and cell phones. These items let us converse with people from all over the world. Without having to travel on a horse and buggy for 10,000 miles.

    ReplyDelete
  23. the one that said moose trax. is mine. im not sure why that came up and not my name but this is ally kaufman

    ReplyDelete
  24. Emerson's quote relates to part one of the book by society never being balanced. Winston wanted a change and freedom. To get that change you have to take a risk. Which is kinda of what he is doing with the proles. Even though using the proles is a huge risk he is willing to do it for freedom. The quote also states "for everything that is given, something is taken." it shows that as we advance we get rid of what is old and don't need anymore. As Big Brother took over the society advanced and lost more and more of what it had before. GAINING Newspeak the former way of talking or writting was replaced and all old records were destroyed. Freedom today is slowy going away with being able to track anyone whenever using credit card records.

    Katie W

    ReplyDelete
  25. In correlation to Part I of 1984, the philosophy that society never advances is held true. In order to gain, Big Brother takes away. Making language more efficient, the government eliminates most of the old vocabulary, creating Newspeak. In order to create more efficiency, they take away the extras of life, such as the nicer tasting food. They also monitor their Party members at all time, so as to not run the risk of having dissenters in the Party. In relation to today's society, the same is also true. We have sacrificed the knowledge of what our government does for national security and peace. The majority of our government policies are kept in secret from the public, at least until a later date.

    ReplyDelete