"The mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation. What is called resignation is confirmed desperation" (Thoreau). Discuss this quote in general terms and in relation to the novel or movie.
First I would like to say that Grayson's kingdom has officially joined with Adam's feudal system in exchange for free laboring serfs, and wenches. Also, we have joined with Doug's kingdom and still plan on attacking Amanda in 4th block... The mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation can only mean that the lives that people have are not really the ones that they want. People say they want certain lives, but once they finally get that life, they secretely want it changed. This can be seen in the book when the government controls everything. There is stability, and the people seem content... Some of the dumber ones are content, but a lot of them secretely want the freedom to do what they want and live the lives that they want. This can also be seen in the movie Minority Report when the people are safe from murders due to the government. They seem happy because they are safe, but at the same time, a lot of them want the freedom to make their own decisionz, including the decision to commit murder. lol
Hello all. I just wantted to express my gratitude towards all of you for your support. We have taken over the kingdom of dougdum. All of its followers are now united under our banner of GRAYSON'S COUNTRY IS THE BEST EVERopia. I have made some revisions too the original courts. Paige is now the princess due to her constant nagging... i mean polite asking. =) Ally has moved up to take her position as jester. Emily has been added to court aswell. Her position is to be the court talker. Mrs. Stallman a.k.a. Gramemr Checkerer should agree with this disicion. Matt and Kurt have been added to the counsil aswell. They are my "royal party peeps". They plan everything for me. We will be throwing a dance party here soon where we are to stompith the yardith. Doug has been added to the court aswell as the royal warlord of nothingness. (now time to do my actually post)That is all from the kingdom today. from your king Grayson the XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXIV
The mass of men lead lives of quite desperation can only mean that even though you can see and interact with people, the person you see is not the same person inside. What I mean is when you go and live your life there is something that you always regret. maybe its the man you married (danny) or maybe its a job you did not take. You can not always see this on the outside hence the term "quite desperation". This is related to the book because the main charactor (cant think of name atm) secretly hates Big brother. Others can not tell this though at the very beggining and thus he lives a life of "quite depression".
And I would also like to note that I have only agreed to these terms because as of now, I am still in control of my original land and am now the official warlord of both kingdoms. Anyway, this quote means most people live quite lives in which contain desperation, or just struggles. I believe this is true in both the nόvel and real life. Most citizens of America and 85% of the population of Oceania are just the average joe. Most of both of these types of people are living quite lives, making no huge impact on humanity. And this desperation Thoreau talks about may be actual intense desperation or it could just be everyday struggles people go through.
______When Thoreau says "The mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation," he means that most members of society have a sense of hopelessness that they carry with them at all times, but rarely show. In 1984, the citizens of Oceania hide their true emotions, making it near impossible for any real understanding between them. Therefore, those who disapprove of the party and its morals can't truly talk to their fellow rebels and this fact elicits an extreme feeling of hopelessness, that can't be suppressed easily. Resignation is submitting without resistance, and when Thoreau says "resignation is confirmed desperation," he is merely explaining how hopelessness builds up and eventually will cause a human being to submit to a greater authority without thinking of defying the ideals of the authority. This is represented in 1984, where Big Brother is the commanding authority and most of the citizens of Oceania succumb to the ideals of the party.
Thoreau's quote means that the people secretly regret and don't like this new change in their lives. When he says "What is called resignation is confirmed desperation", he means that they regret agreeing to this new change, and now they are in a state of despiration. IN relation to the novel, the community of Oceania regrets letting Big Brother come to power. They truly want their old lives back (whatever their old lives were; most people have forgotten what they were like). However, they lead "quiet lives" because if they show any signs of rebellion, they would be vaporized. In relation to Minority Report, John, as well as the rest of the country, regrets bringing PreCrime to the attention of the government. If PreCrime never existed, innocent people might not have been put into prison for "almost attempting" or "considering" murder.
When Thoreau says that "men lead lives of quiet desperation" I think he is saying that everyone has a sense of sadness or unhappiness but refuses to show it. This is greatly shown in 1984. In 1984 all of the people have a sense of hopelessness but in fear it is never aknowledged. "Resignation is confirmed desperation" is also greatly seen in the novel. Thorea is saying that by submitting to all orders/rules a person is admitting to their desperation. Their desperation leads them to basically give up and just listen. This is true for all members of the party in 1984. The party members do exactly as they're told because they feel there is no other way.
Most people keep the items that they desperately want to themselves. They never act to make these items happen. They simply give up and resign. This resignation shows that what they desperately want stays hidden and quiet. In the novel, the Party members are forced not to do any action that might show that they are against the Party. even if they desperately want to overthrow the Party, they have to keep quiet. They can't even make faces without the government in the from of Big Brother taking them out.
The mass body of civilization yearns to go on "advendures" and do something other than work. They have hopes, dreams, and goals that are not relevent to everyday life/workplace. Not always being able to strive for this, people keep it quiet, as Thoreau suggests, so that no one knows about it. One one resigns for all attempts of yearning for more, they become quietly desperate, carrying that desperate feeling but never acting on it or showing signs of desperation. In 1984, Winston lives in quiet desperation of one day becoming free and independent of strong government control. He keeps a diary and tells no one of his true fellings except...
I think Thoreau is saying that although "the mass of men" may appear happy as a whole, individually there are things that people are unhappy with. A group of people may be generally happy, but there may be a few people who are unhappy or are dealing with In 1984, the population as a whole seems to be content, but there are people, such as Winston and Julia who are not. These people act like they are happy and they support the Party when they are around other people, but secretly they are unhappy and want to overthrow Big Brother. They are afraid to openly discuss these things because of the telescreens. Only when they are alone and away from the "mass of men" can they discuss their true feelings.
I just posted an amazing response and blogger had an error. I think I should automatically just get 100% anyways but since I am an overachiever I will try to retype another one that is, if we're lucky, at least half as amazing.
First of all I would like to address the merger between Doug's Kingdom, which I was a part of, and Grayson's kingdom. As part of the settlement during 4th block ,Grayson officially named me The Lord of the Rings.
As for Thoreau I believe his quote is saying that everyone has vats of emotion that they hide away. Everyone has hopes and dreams and feelings which they conceal from the rest of society so that they may fit in and be normal. When people resign these feelings and stuff they are disappointed and despair. "Resignation is confirmed desperation." In 1986 everyone tries to fit into society so that they are not killed by the Thought pOlice. Everyone resigns their feelings when they conform to society and pretend to love big brotha . In Oceania most people probably hate the party but ironically they ignore these feelings so that they may fit in with everyone else. While I don't necessarily completely agree with Thoreau’s quote I still think it sounds kinda cool.
btw i couldn't understand your comment Mrs. Stallman. im thinkn alex should be Gramemr Checkerer from now on. i shall have to consult with the King.
I think that Thoreau is saying that all people have private thoughts of discontent that they do not share with other people. Most people will not be happy where they are in life. If you have resigned to the face that you cannot advance your position in life then that is proof that you are discontent. In 1984, Winston has private thoughts of rebellion and hate towards Big Brother. He has accepted the fact that he will not be able to do anything about this, rather, he accepts that he has essentially put himself to death. Many other people in 1984's society have secret hate for Big Brother, as you can see by the many people that have been vaporized for thoughtcrime. Actually, what Thoreau is describing in this quote is a very good definition of thoughtcrime.
I believe that the quote is saying people do have thoughts that they don't want to share with others. Also that everyone has hidden emotions. And usually the emotions that we hide are angry or sad ones. We usually hide them by putting on a happy front for everyone. This relates to 1084 because Winston actually does not like Big Brother. But in the beginning of the novel during the two minute hate he just goes along with everyone else and cheers for Big Brother. He then finds himself writing "Down with big Brother."
Hahaha i appreciate being moved up to jester grayson. i knew i could reason with you. What this quote is saying is that all men have their private thoughts about everything that no one else can hear. Their private lives are sometimes wayy different different than the life that they portray to other people. He is also saying that when you give in and show people how bad you are actually suffering, everyone then knows. Resignation is another word for showing everyone everything terrible that's going on in your life. This relates to the novel because a lot of people in the book could dislike big brother as wintston does but they wont tell anyone. telling people would be like resigning and just giving in to big brother. they need to go about hating him in their private life and not letting anyone else know
and does GTFY mean going to fail you? haha Grayson i dont want to be the jester
I am very excited to be the "court talker," I think I will fill this position well. :-)
In this quote I think that Thoreau is saying the majority of people live their lives always desperate for something more than what they are given. Society can not provide a perfect balance of everything that an individual would want in his or her lifetime. This relates to 1984 when Watson is desperate for the freedoms that are taken away by Big Brother. He does not tell anyone else of his desperation in Part I of the novel. Others in the 1984 society also have desperations and are not contempt with the current state of their society. All the possible people that could perhaps be envisioning a hypothetical coup of Big Brother keep their mouths' shut and their thoughts secret.
In this quote I think Thoreau is saying that alot of people live their life without showing sadness and unhappiness. They hide this by putting on a face that shows happiness and joy that is just a fake. In 1984 Winston does this in part one by the constant thoughts of trying to get rid of Big Brother. Also during the two minute hate, he goes along with everyone even thought what he is truly feeling is the opposite. Winston might not be the only one though there could be others like him who choose to just keep their mouths' and put on their happy faces.
Ally, you ROCK! You figured out the message by realizing what I want to do to them given their horrific grammar...which means I should remain the gramemer checkerrer. Hannah, I decided to create a language that was difficult for your generation since you keep writing with codes us "nublets" do not understand (or have to consult the evil internet to learn!)
btw, fyi i r qb of my own kingdom...you should all hail to me unless you think that my threat of gtfy is empty...
Ally, and Mrs. Stallman, I think you're wrong. I think GTFY means Going To Fight You. I'M EXCITED. CAGE MATCH GO.I can almost guarantee that the quote Thoreau makes here relates to man's struggle of finding what they want in life. By "leading lives of quiet desperation," they are constantly despairing over what they want to do, what they want to find, and basically, just what they want. When they "confirm their desperation," they realize that they don't know what exactly they want, but the mindset still doesn't quell their desperation. In terms of the novel, Winston is constantly desperate to find out what the truth is. He needs clarity in his life, and he is desperate to find it. All of the Party members don't have this desperation, this need, because they have been brainwashed to not have the need. The Party leaders have completely erased the desire from their minds, which allows for a free-flowing society, and perfect harmony. No discontent can arise if there is nothing for the discontent to form from.
I believe that Thoreau's quote is duscussing the desparity that people find in their lives. Growing up, many believe they are going to live heroic and interesting lives. Only later realizing this not to be the case. Having unexciting lives, doing mundane monotonous work day in and day out. People wanting to live other lives and experience exciting things, but being unable to do so. In the book Winston does the same work everyday, going through the same routine with nothing to look forward to. He always wants to commit thought crime or join the proles, but realizing it is impossible for him to do so.
P.S. As everyone who has posted on here as my witness I am now declaring a new kingdom. The Kingdom of the Arc. As the ruler of this new kingdom I am going to neeed serfs as well as warlords to fiht for me. Therefore i am establishing positions, they are as follows: Grayson- The Infected One Mrs. Stallman- The Dragon Myself- Beowulf Danny-Lancelot Paige-Guinevere Jessica-Legolas Doug-Gimly All else are higher more important roles among my council, Thank you that is all.
I think that Thoreau's quote speaks of a matter of position. While a man, born into a situation where he knows no other, may be consciencely* content, most are not. The proles, for example, are content with their lives. This contentness, however, is bred from ignorance of their situation. Everyone knows envy, though. As soon as you are aware of someone with something better you crave to equal or surpass them, if only on a sub-conscience level. From that drive, you either find solace with that fact, "resignation is confirmed desperation," or an ambition, which drives you do better.
Hey People! Why don't I have a role in any court, thanks guys. But if you want me to fill Ally's place as peasant, I might prefer not to have a role. Mrs. Stallman DFTSFTT tomorrow? Don't forget to study for the test tomorrow?
Anyway, I believe that Thoreau is trying to say that men want different things in life than what they usually receive. As for Winston, he wants to have the life of a prole in some ways. He doesn't want to be watched or have no choices or freedoms, he wants to live in what would make him content. You always want someone else's life or different characteristics in your life, you live in quiet desperation.
ah i see there is rebellion in my kingdom. very well then. I CHALLANGE YOU TO AN HONORABLE DUEL! Noah and I shallist do combat to see who the ruler of the land is. If he wins he can break of and take my land with him seeing as we are fighting to the death. On an important note we have taken over 4th block... regretibly i have to move paige to court jester again as part of the agreement terms. Ally you can now take the place of head queen. Sean i dub thee Lord Pooper Scooper. You will be the grounds man.... of death. Michelle you can be my royal homework dooooer. As of now. please rewrite my blog. That is all.
Oops, I accidentily put my last post in L337speak (that's leetspeak for all you squares). I translated it back...
I think Thoreau means to say that as as you get older, you realize that all the cool, adventurous things you wanted to do as an adult when you were a child become impossible to achieve. Your life becomes more realistic as you are faced with going to work every day, doing the same thing over, and over, and over, and over. Citizens need excitement, vacations, events, things to look forward to. In the novel, Winston has nothing to look forward to (except meeting with his secret agent friend) and becomes quite uneasy and dissatisfied with his mundane life.
This quote talks about how giving up isn't actually accepting the facts. Even after giving up, people still want to fix their problems. They continue about their lives, hoping for change, but doing nothing to cause that change they so desire to come about. In 1984, the people are not resigning themselves to their fate, as they truly beleive that their world is as good as it can be and that there is nothing wrong. However, some people who realize that The Party is not always right and lies to them cannot accept this, but being powerless to change it, continue on desparately. Winston and Julia accept that they will not see the party fall in their lives and that they will be caught by the thought Police at one point, regardless of how careful they are.
First I would like to say that Grayson's kingdom has officially joined with Adam's feudal system in exchange for free laboring serfs, and wenches. Also, we have joined with Doug's kingdom and still plan on attacking Amanda in 4th block...
ReplyDeleteThe mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation can only mean that the lives that people have are not really the ones that they want. People say they want certain lives, but once they finally get that life, they secretely want it changed. This can be seen in the book when the government controls everything. There is stability, and the people seem content... Some of the dumber ones are content, but a lot of them secretely want the freedom to do what they want and live the lives that they want. This can also be seen in the movie Minority Report when the people are safe from murders due to the government. They seem happy because they are safe, but at the same time, a lot of them want the freedom to make their own decisionz, including the decision to commit murder.
lol
Hello all. I just wantted to express my gratitude towards all of you for your support. We have taken over the kingdom of dougdum. All of its followers are now united under our banner of GRAYSON'S COUNTRY IS THE BEST EVERopia. I have made some revisions too the original courts. Paige is now the princess due to her constant nagging... i mean polite asking. =) Ally has moved up to take her position as jester. Emily has been added to court aswell. Her position is to be the court talker. Mrs. Stallman a.k.a. Gramemr Checkerer should agree with this disicion. Matt and Kurt have been added to the counsil aswell. They are my "royal party peeps". They plan everything for me. We will be throwing a dance party here soon where we are to stompith the yardith. Doug has been added to the court aswell as the royal warlord of nothingness. (now time to do my actually post)That is all from the kingdom today.
ReplyDeletefrom your king
Grayson the XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXIV
The mass of men lead lives of quite desperation can only mean that even though you can see and interact with people, the person you see is not the same person inside. What I mean is when you go and live your life there is something that you always regret. maybe its the man you married (danny) or maybe its a job you did not take. You can not always see this on the outside hence the term "quite desperation". This is related to the book because the main charactor (cant think of name atm) secretly hates Big brother. Others can not tell this though at the very beggining and thus he lives a life of "quite depression".
ReplyDeleteAnd I would also like to note that I have only agreed to these terms because as of now, I am still in control of my original land and am now the official warlord of both kingdoms.
ReplyDeleteAnyway, this quote means most people live quite lives in which contain desperation, or just struggles. I believe this is true in both the nόvel and real life. Most citizens of America and 85% of the population of Oceania are just the average joe. Most of both of these types of people are living quite lives, making no huge impact on humanity. And this desperation Thoreau talks about may be actual intense desperation or it could just be everyday struggles people go through.
______When Thoreau says "The mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation," he means that most members of society have a sense of hopelessness that they carry with them at all times, but rarely show. In 1984, the citizens of Oceania hide their true emotions, making it near impossible for any real understanding between them. Therefore, those who disapprove of the party and its morals can't truly talk to their fellow rebels and this fact elicits an extreme feeling of hopelessness, that can't be suppressed easily. Resignation is submitting without resistance, and when Thoreau says "resignation is confirmed desperation," he is merely explaining how hopelessness builds up and eventually will cause a human being to submit to a greater authority without thinking of defying the ideals of the authority. This is represented in 1984, where Big Brother is the commanding authority and most of the citizens of Oceania succumb to the ideals of the party.
ReplyDeleteP.S. I was getting annoyed by not being able to indent a paragraph.
ReplyDeleteThoreau's quote means that the people secretly regret and don't like this new change in their lives. When he says "What is called resignation is confirmed desperation", he means that they regret agreeing to this new change, and now they are in a state of despiration. IN relation to the novel, the community of Oceania regrets letting Big Brother come to power. They truly want their old lives back (whatever their old lives were; most people have forgotten what they were like). However, they lead "quiet lives" because if they show any signs of rebellion, they would be vaporized. In relation to Minority Report, John, as well as the rest of the country, regrets bringing PreCrime to the attention of the government. If PreCrime never existed, innocent people might not have been put into prison for "almost attempting" or "considering" murder.
ReplyDeleteWhen Thoreau says that "men lead lives of quiet desperation" I think he is saying that everyone has a sense of sadness or unhappiness but refuses to show it. This is greatly shown in 1984. In 1984 all of the people have a sense of hopelessness but in fear it is never aknowledged. "Resignation is confirmed desperation" is also greatly seen in the novel. Thorea is saying that by submitting to all orders/rules a person is admitting to their desperation. Their desperation leads them to basically give up and just listen. This is true for all members of the party in 1984. The party members do exactly as they're told because they feel there is no other way.
ReplyDeleteDanny, I am GTFY. Figure that one out!
ReplyDeleteAlex, I love that grammatical/writing inadequacies annoy you!
Grayson, I truly hope your spelling atrocities are intentional; otherwise, I am GTFY too.
The rest of you, DFTSFTT tomorrow.
The Leet Nublet???
Most people keep the items that they desperately want to themselves. They never act to make these items happen. They simply give up and resign. This resignation shows that what they desperately want stays hidden and quiet. In the novel, the Party members are forced not to do any action that might show that they are against the Party. even if they desperately want to overthrow the Party, they have to keep quiet. They can't even make faces without the government in the from of Big Brother taking them out.
ReplyDeleteThe mass body of civilization yearns to go on "advendures" and do something other than work. They have hopes, dreams, and goals that are not relevent to everyday life/workplace. Not always being able to strive for this, people keep it quiet, as Thoreau suggests, so that no one knows about it. One one resigns for all attempts of yearning for more, they become quietly desperate, carrying that desperate feeling but never acting on it or showing signs of desperation. In 1984, Winston lives in quiet desperation of one day becoming free and independent of strong government control. He keeps a diary and tells no one of his true fellings except...
ReplyDeleteI think Thoreau is saying that although "the mass of men" may appear happy as a whole, individually there are things that people are unhappy with. A group of people may be generally happy, but there may be a few people who are unhappy or are dealing with In 1984, the population as a whole seems to be content, but there are people, such as Winston and Julia who are not. These people act like they are happy and they support the Party when they are around other people, but secretly they are unhappy and want to overthrow Big Brother. They are afraid to openly discuss these things because of the telescreens. Only when they are alone and away from the "mass of men" can they discuss their true feelings.
ReplyDeleteoops. My second sentance should end with "dealing with problems."
ReplyDeleteI just posted an amazing response and blogger had an error. I think I should automatically just get 100% anyways but since I am an overachiever I will try to retype another one that is, if we're lucky, at least half as amazing.
ReplyDeleteFirst of all I would like to address the merger between Doug's Kingdom, which I was a part of, and Grayson's kingdom. As part of the settlement during 4th block ,Grayson officially named me The Lord of the Rings.
As for Thoreau I believe his quote is saying that everyone has vats of emotion that they hide away. Everyone has hopes and dreams and feelings which they conceal from the rest of society so that they may fit in and be normal. When people resign these feelings and stuff they are disappointed and despair. "Resignation is confirmed desperation." In 1986 everyone tries to fit into society so that they are not killed by the Thought pOlice. Everyone resigns their feelings when they conform to society and pretend to love big brotha . In Oceania most people probably hate the party but ironically they ignore these feelings so that they may fit in with everyone else. While I don't necessarily completely agree with Thoreau’s quote I still think it sounds kinda cool.
btw i couldn't understand your comment Mrs. Stallman. im thinkn alex should be Gramemr Checkerer from now on. i shall have to consult with the King.
I think that Thoreau is saying that all people have private thoughts of discontent that they do not share with other people. Most people will not be happy where they are in life. If you have resigned to the face that you cannot advance your position in life then that is proof that you are discontent. In 1984, Winston has private thoughts of rebellion and hate towards Big Brother. He has accepted the fact that he will not be able to do anything about this, rather, he accepts that he has essentially put himself to death. Many other people in 1984's society have secret hate for Big Brother, as you can see by the many people that have been vaporized for thoughtcrime. Actually, what Thoreau is describing in this quote is a very good definition of thoughtcrime.
ReplyDeleteOMG Mrs. Stallman, you can't just make up random abreviations!lol :-)
ReplyDeleteI believe that the quote is saying people do have thoughts that they don't want to share with others. Also that everyone has hidden emotions. And usually the emotions that we hide are angry or sad ones. We usually hide them by putting on a happy front for everyone. This relates to 1084 because Winston actually does not like Big Brother. But in the beginning of the novel during the two minute hate he just goes along with everyone else and cheers for Big Brother. He then finds himself writing "Down with big Brother."
ReplyDeleteHahaha i appreciate being moved up to jester grayson. i knew i could reason with you.
ReplyDeleteWhat this quote is saying is that all men have their private thoughts about everything that no one else can hear. Their private lives are sometimes wayy different different than the life that they portray to other people. He is also saying that when you give in and show people how bad you are actually suffering, everyone then knows. Resignation is another word for showing everyone everything terrible that's going on in your life. This relates to the novel because a lot of people in the book could dislike big brother as wintston does but they wont tell anyone. telling people would be like resigning and just giving in to big brother. they need to go about hating him in their private life and not letting anyone else know
and does GTFY mean going to fail you? haha Grayson i dont want to be the jester
I am very excited to be the "court talker," I think I will fill this position well. :-)
ReplyDeleteIn this quote I think that Thoreau is saying the majority of people live their lives always desperate for something more than what they are given. Society can not provide a perfect balance of everything that an individual would want in his or her lifetime. This relates to 1984 when Watson is desperate for the freedoms that are taken away by Big Brother. He does not tell anyone else of his desperation in Part I of the novel. Others in the 1984 society also have desperations and are not contempt with the current state of their society. All the possible people that could perhaps be envisioning a hypothetical coup of Big Brother keep their mouths' shut and their thoughts secret.
In this quote I think Thoreau is saying that alot of people live their life without showing sadness and unhappiness. They hide this by putting on a face that shows happiness and joy that is just a fake. In 1984 Winston does this in part one by the constant thoughts of trying to get rid of Big Brother. Also during the two minute hate, he goes along with everyone even thought what he is truly feeling is the opposite. Winston might not be the only one though there could be others like him who choose to just keep their mouths' and put on their happy faces.
ReplyDeleteAlly, you ROCK! You figured out the message by realizing what I want to do to them given their horrific grammar...which means I should remain the gramemer checkerrer. Hannah, I decided to create a language that was difficult for your generation since you keep writing with codes us "nublets" do not understand (or have to consult the evil internet to learn!)
ReplyDeletebtw, fyi i r qb of my own kingdom...you should all hail to me unless you think that my threat of gtfy is empty...
Peace to the leet; power to the nublets
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteAlly, and Mrs. Stallman, I think you're wrong.
ReplyDeleteI think GTFY means Going To Fight You.
I'M EXCITED.
CAGE MATCH GO.I can almost guarantee that the quote Thoreau makes here relates to man's struggle of finding what they want in life. By "leading lives of quiet desperation," they are constantly despairing over what they want to do, what they want to find, and basically, just what they want. When they "confirm their desperation," they realize that they don't know what exactly they want, but the mindset still doesn't quell their desperation. In terms of the novel, Winston is constantly desperate to find out what the truth is. He needs clarity in his life, and he is desperate to find it. All of the Party members don't have this desperation, this need, because they have been brainwashed to not have the need. The Party leaders have completely erased the desire from their minds, which allows for a free-flowing society, and perfect harmony. No discontent can arise if there is nothing for the discontent to form from.
Agh HTML error.
ReplyDeleteThere should be a line split between cage match and the answer to the prompt.
NOT MY FAULT.
I believe that Thoreau's quote is duscussing the desparity that people find in their lives. Growing up, many believe they are going to live heroic and interesting lives. Only later realizing this not to be the case. Having unexciting lives, doing mundane monotonous work day in and day out. People wanting to live other lives and experience exciting things, but being unable to do so. In the book Winston does the same work everyday, going through the same routine with nothing to look forward to. He always wants to commit thought crime or join the proles, but realizing it is impossible for him to do so.
ReplyDeleteP.S. As everyone who has posted on here as my witness I am now declaring a new kingdom. The Kingdom of the Arc. As the ruler of this new kingdom I am going to neeed serfs as well as warlords to fiht for me. Therefore i am establishing positions, they are as follows:
Grayson- The Infected One
Mrs. Stallman- The Dragon
Myself- Beowulf
Danny-Lancelot
Paige-Guinevere
Jessica-Legolas
Doug-Gimly
All else are higher more important roles among my council, Thank you that is all.
I think that Thoreau's quote speaks of a matter of position. While a man, born into a situation where he knows no other, may be consciencely* content, most are not. The proles, for example, are content with their lives. This contentness, however, is bred from ignorance of their situation. Everyone knows envy, though. As soon as you are aware of someone with something better you crave to equal or surpass them, if only on a sub-conscience level. From that drive, you either find solace with that fact, "resignation is confirmed desperation," or an ambition, which drives you do better.
ReplyDeleteHey People! Why don't I have a role in any court, thanks guys. But if you want me to fill Ally's place as peasant, I might prefer not to have a role. Mrs. Stallman DFTSFTT tomorrow? Don't forget to study for the test tomorrow?
ReplyDeleteAnyway, I believe that Thoreau is trying to say that men want different things in life than what they usually receive. As for Winston, he wants to have the life of a prole in some ways. He doesn't want to be watched or have no choices or freedoms, he wants to live in what would make him content. You always want someone else's life or different characteristics in your life, you live in quiet desperation.
ah i see there is rebellion in my kingdom. very well then. I CHALLANGE YOU TO AN HONORABLE DUEL! Noah and I shallist do combat to see who the ruler of the land is. If he wins he can break of and take my land with him seeing as we are fighting to the death. On an important note we have taken over 4th block... regretibly i have to move paige to court jester again as part of the agreement terms. Ally you can now take the place of head queen. Sean i dub thee Lord Pooper Scooper. You will be the grounds man.... of death. Michelle you can be my royal homework dooooer. As of now. please rewrite my blog. That is all.
ReplyDelete|-|4|-|4 \/\/3LL, 4Ph73R 4LL 7|-|@ |-|00PL4|-|, 1 7|-|1|\||< 7|-|0R34U /\/\34|\|5 70 54'/ 7|-|@ 45 45 j00Z 937 0LD3R, j00Z r34L1Z3 7|-|@ 4LL 7|-|3 (00L, 4D\/3|\|7UR0U5 7|-|1|\|95 j00Z \/\/4|\|73D 70 d0 45 4|\| 4DUL7 \/\/|-|3|\| j00Z \/\/3R3 4 (|-|1LD b3(0/\/\3 1/\/\P0551BL3 70 4(|-|13\/3. '/0UR L1Ph3 b3(0/\/\35 /\/\0R3 r34L1571( 45 j00Z r Ph4(3D \/\/17|-| 901|\|9 70 \/\/0R|< 3\/3R'/ d4'/, d01|\|9 7|-|3 54/\/\3 7|-|1|\|9 0\/3R, 4|\|D 0\/3R, 4|\|D 0\/3R, 4|\|D 0\/3R. (171Z3|\|5 |\|33D 3><(173/\/\3|\|7, \/4(4710|\|5, 3\/3|\|75, 7|-|1|\|95 70 L00|< Ph0R\/\/4RD 70. 1|\| 7|-|3 |\|0\/3L, \/\/1|\|570|\| |-|45 |\|07|-|1|\|9 70 L00|< Ph0R\/\/4RD 70 (3><(3P7 /\/\3371|\|9 \/\/17|-| |-|15 53(R37 493|\|7 PhR13|\|D) 4|\|D b3(0/\/\35 QU173 U|\|345'/ 4|\|D d1554715Ph13D \/\/17|-| |-|15 /\/\U|\|D4|\|3 L1Ph3.
ReplyDeleteOops, I accidentily put my last post in L337speak (that's leetspeak for all you squares). I translated it back...
ReplyDeleteI think Thoreau means to say that as as you get older, you realize that all the cool, adventurous things you wanted to do as an adult when you were a child become impossible to achieve. Your life becomes more realistic as you are faced with going to work every day, doing the same thing over, and over, and over, and over. Citizens need excitement, vacations, events, things to look forward to. In the novel, Winston has nothing to look forward to (except meeting with his secret agent friend) and becomes quite uneasy and dissatisfied with his mundane life.
This quote talks about how giving up isn't actually accepting the facts. Even after giving up, people still want to fix their problems. They continue about their lives, hoping for change, but doing nothing to cause that change they so desire to come about. In 1984, the people are not resigning themselves to their fate, as they truly beleive that their world is as good as it can be and that there is nothing wrong. However, some people who realize that The Party is not always right and lies to them cannot accept this, but being powerless to change it, continue on desparately. Winston and Julia accept that they will not see the party fall in their lives and that they will be caught by the thought Police at one point, regardless of how careful they are.
ReplyDelete