"Society is a wave. The wave moves onward, but the water of which it is composed does not. The same particle does not rise from the valley to the ridge. Its unity is only phenomenal. The persons who make up a nation to-day, next year die, and their experience dies with them" (Emerson).
Discuss this quote as best you can in general terms as well as in relation to Part I of the novel.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
This quote is saying that the "wave" or society is always moving foward and changing. Emerson is saying that one day people are a part of our world and in the next day they can be gone forever. This is similar to the "vaporizing" that occurs in the novel. Emerson is trying to say that as people die and leave our society/world usually their knowledge and experience leaves with them. When Emerson says "but the water of which it is composed does not" I believe he is saying that the actual base of society never really changes or moves foward just the people move foward. This relates to part I of the novel because it is exactly how that society operates. They are constantly changing the past and the people who expierenced the true past and remember it(different enemies in war for example) are low in number. The people who know the true past are forced to act as if they believe the governments truth. When those people die their truth goes with them and society never realizes that the world was once a different place. Soon enough no one will ever remember what truely used to be.
ReplyDeleteThe quote is saying that in a society, the people do not make progress, only the society itself. The people may make an accomplishment but they will soon die and their accomplishment will be forgotten. The society in 1984 changes history to make their society better. The accomplishments of others are forgotten for the better of the society, and the people who oppose the society are disposed of. In the story, everybody has to have their freedoms taken away for the society to be perfect in the eyes of the leaderz.
ReplyDeletelol grayson r leet.
When Emerson says "the same particle does not rise from the valley to the ridge," he means that any one person will not rise (or fall, for that matter) in the ranks of the society. This is shown in Part 1 of 1984, where there are proles and party members and Big Brother. Big Brother never steps down, the party members never move up nor down, and the proles never move up. This ladder is so thoroughly engrained into the lives of the people of 1984 that the other factors of society, such as food rationing, technology, etc., can fluctuate without upsetting the balance of power in the citizens of Oceania. When Emerson says the "unity is only phenomenal," he means the unity of the utopian society is exceedingly or unbelievably great, as long as the particles of the social wave stay in their place. Otherwise, the lowest particles of the wave would rise and overpower the particle on top, which , in refenence to 1984, would equal Big Brother. This theory holds true to Winston's belief that the proles, or the lowest particle of the social wave, could easily overpower Big Brother if given a true reason to hold on to. In 1984, their whole society is based on "The persons who make up a nation to-day, next year die, and their experiences die with them." This system is the means for the destruction of the truth in the past. When the oldest citizens within the proles are dead, there will be no one left to tell about what the past was really like and then the past, as it will be known, will be just an illusion created by the government for the purposes of the survival of the party, nothing more.
ReplyDeleteIn relation to 1984, Emerson's quote applies well to Part 1. The society of 1984 may have advanced, or changed, but the people have not. In addition, all of the social classes of 1984 are virtually permanent. What ever class you are born into (proles, Party members, etc) is the social club that you will be apart of all you life and likely your children too. In 1984, peoples ideas die with them. Those who oppose the Party and have rebellious thoughts are "wacked." Their ideas and experiences die with them and society moves on.
ReplyDeleteHello yall your leader is here! I believe what Emerson is saying holds true in the novel and in the book. When Emerson refers to society as a"wave" he is basically saying that you can surf it. By this i mean that in life you will have you high points and your low points. What comes up must come back down. You never truely do "advance" if this is true. Now the same can be said about society. Society itself has its ups and downs but genera;;y stays the same. The only things that change in it are the people day in and day out. This is what Emerson means when he is talking about people living a nation one day, and then dieing the next take part of society with them.
ReplyDeleteoh and btw i am here to announce my royal court:
ReplyDeleteme obviously = king duh
Noah= noob executer and second in comand
Danny= royal court magic man and or taster of all my foods before me in case of posioning
Kevin= court court minstral and court beat boxer
Paige= court jester
Mrs. stallman = gramemr checkerrer
Nathan.... we will just have to exicute
I still need time to come up positions for the rest of you... do not think you are a peasant (reserved for ally). That is all...
P.S. i am leet
This quote is saying that a nation undergoes change that is unnoticed most of the time. In relation to the novel, when a person is "vaporized" by the government, there existence vanishes with them. However, the nation (the wave) keeps on moving without this person in it. When Emerson says "There experience dies with them", he says that they take everything about them with themselves to the after-life. In 1984's society, people, such as Winston, are given the task of deleting all evidence of this person. These people replace the non-existent person with a live one, so it seems like the original person never existed in the first place.
ReplyDeleteWhat Emerson is saying is that a society is only composed of the people who are currently alive and a part of it. The past and future members aren't members at all. They belong to different societies. This relates to the novel. Winston tries to find out from the old man in the bar what a past society was like (the society before big brother took over). Winston wants to know if this former society was better than the current one. Unfortunately, the man can only give him unimportant details about the past instead of giving him a generalization about conditions. Winston is not a part of that society because he was not alive for it (or at least he was to young to count). Even though the two societies share members, they are completely different. America is another good example of this. I am a member of today's American society. So are my parents. I, however, am not a member of the American society of the seventies (thank goodness!!). My parents were. Neither of us were a member of the American society of the 1860s. After all, what is society but a community of people? And how can there be community and communication between the present and the past or future? Therefore society is changing every time someone dies or is born. The world is changing every second.
ReplyDeleteEmerson, in his statement, makes the point that only society changes. The people who make up that society, on the other-hand, do not. While a few people may push for a reform, and even succeed in changing the society in which they exist, most people do not change. As Emerson puts it, "The same particle does not rise from the valley to the ridge." It takes DRASTIC circumstances for people to change. In relation to the novel, everyone follows their caste. There is not existence outside the Party as far they are concerned, and those within are strictly regulated. Anyone who does anything out of the ordinary is eliminated, one way or another (Vaporization).
ReplyDeleteAs for Grayson, the "King of all that is 1337," I'd take a position on your Board of advisees. That or just get invited to parties, whatever.
at least im not a peasant I guess
ReplyDeleteAs for emerson's qoute I think hes talking about how society moves on and advances but the people that make it up stay the same. The traditions we have in our society are passed down from older generations. We may learn about history but the actual experiences that people personally had will die out. What we leave behind is a wave on the rest of society. In 1986 the people who remember life before the revolution are slowly dying out and since history is rewritten their memories and experiences are forgotten. As everyone eventually learns newspeak and forgets oldspeak ideas such as liberty and freedom will die out too. The revolutionaries and Big Brother created this ingsoc and their influence will be like a wave throughout the generations to come. Each new person just makes up a part of the same ever moving and ever changing society.
hey grayson what about doug? if your the king he most be a god or something
ReplyDeleteIn 1984, the government is constantly changing their recorded history to make people believe what they want them to believe. Therefore, if you were alive before the government made a certain change in its history, you would have to pretend that the government was telling the truth so everyone else would believe it. Then as soon as you die, that knowledge of what really happened dies with you. Society or the "wave" keeps advancing but the people in the society do not, they are the "water" in which stays still and does not advance, because the government doesn't want them to.
ReplyDeleteor the pope, doug could be a pope
ReplyDeleteEmerson is saying that while society changes and moves forward, the people in it do not. Also, in 1984, history is always being rewritten, so that makes society change because history is always changing. As the older people die, the old history and oldspeak become more and more forgotten until nobody remembers them anymore. Also, technology in 1984 has greatly advanced, but the living conditions of the people in the society have not. The Party changes the history from day to day to tell the people that living conditions and food rations are better when they are, in fact, worse.
ReplyDeleteOkay, accordng to Grayson, I am the "gramemr checkerrer," which, I think, means I get to make grammar rules in this cyber space we call our class blog. Although I realize you tend to make spelling errors due to how ferociously you are writing (as a resulf of your enthusiasm), I am now BANNING you from confusing YOUR and YOU'RE (Nathan!) Seriously, stop making this so painful for me!
ReplyDeletep.s. Grayson, I am okay with you handing out titles, as long as you do not make Noah your queen...
In the quote by Emerson he makes it clear that the society is constantly changing but people are not. People are here one day and gone the next. Such as 1984 when someone dies all the records of their life goes with them. So in a way the past is dead. As an old person dies oldspeak dies with them. The past is constantly being rewritten in order to make nobody believe what they once knew. Society is the "wave" Emerson speaks of and the people are the "water" which stays the same and doesn't advance.
ReplyDeleteI believe that Emerson's quote is saying how individuals play such little roles in the more grand make up of things. People live and die, and life continues on as it always has. Any single person cannot be the key to the larger society. In 1984 people constantly disapeared, being "vaporized". Society and life however continued on as it always had.
ReplyDeleteRoflcopter chupchupchup.
P.S. Grayson has staph, therefore not leet
I interpret Emerson's quote to mean that you can't have a continuing society. Once one generation dies, so do their ideas, beliefs, and philosophies, unless they had managed to brainwash and teach their entire offspring generation the exact same principles. This is shown slightly in Part I of 1984, when Winston is describing the monstrosities of children of his neighbors; he describes all children to be monsters and almost evil. They act nothing like the adults; they are much more interested in the well-being of the Party and absolutely no other idea. He gives light to the idea that once the first generation of Party members dies out, the new generation will have absolutely no recollection of the past before the Party, and the "transformation" will have become complete; there will be no arguments or dissenters to speak of.
ReplyDeleteI felt left out of the 13375P34K party soooo...
MRS. STALLMAN = NUBLET.
resulf = TYPOFAIL.
LAWLZ.
Court beat boxer is in the house...
ReplyDeleteGenerally the quote describes how a society can become extremely advanced while most of the people in it stay at the same level as they always were. People still can not rise easily above the social class they are in. Especially the people in the lowest class, who can't organize themselves enough to make their lives better. In 1984, even people in the party do not have more advanced lives than we have now. They still have to obey laws of a government and they have not risen at all in power. There are still Thought Police that can arrest them.
All hail King Grayson
In this quote, Emerson is basically saying that the individual should be the bigger focus than the society as a whole. He says that once someone dies, their experience dies with them. Emerson makes no mention in this quote of the significance of an individual's place in a society, proving that he thinks the individual is more important than the society. He says that the wave is like the bigger picture and if you looked at a wave, you might think that the water is moving but looking more closely, most of the water isn’t really going anywhere. He is also saying that if you are in a society, you can't truly be free. If you do not belong to a society, you can do or go wherever you want. This relates to Part I of 1984 because Watson feels that he is deprived of freedoms because of the society that he is in.
ReplyDeleteThe quote by Emerson states "Society is a wave. The wave moves onward, but the water of which it is composed does not." By this I believe he means that everyday our society is advancing. But some of the people who are not used to these advancements do not advance with our society. For example nowadays teenagers and some adults like to use a lot of technological items. Like cell phones, computers, iPods, etc. And older people are really not that into such a thing. Most old people can barely work a cell phone and they also don't really care to learn either.
ReplyDeleteIn 1984 their government is ruled by Big Brother and everyone who is born into the Big Brother society goes by what they are taught. As for the older people who were alive when they switched over to Big Brother probably didn't really like the change. But as each year goes on with Big Brother intact the older people would die leaving everything before Big Brother in the past and the new people who were born would know nothing about the old society. So they just simply follow what they are taught.
testing...
ReplyDeleteI personally believe that this means that society moves on without us after we die, and how insignificant the individual is to society as a whole. the wave inexorably continues onwards with no regard for the individuals it leaves behind. society ignores the experiences others had and continues. In 1984, the government deliberately forces society to move forward and forget about the past, leaving it only in people's memories. when those people die, there is no evidence of the past anymore.
ReplyDeleteNathan: Since now you apparently think I'm a god or something, would you like to join me in a rival kingdom against Grayson's??
ReplyDeleteAnyway, I'm not sure but I think Emerson is saying (with the "wave thing") that societies advance, that's their main purpose, to have progress. As the government and leaders move on, the people are taken with it, but they don't necesarily understand, the just "go with the flow" and conform to their leaders. This is shown in 1984 through the proles. Big Brother changes everything and the majority of the population (proles) just goes with it, continues their own way of life, and don't contribute anything to the effort. When he talks about the particle, he might mean, in society, when someone starts a movement or anything else, it takes a long time and they usually don't see what comes out of their begginning effort. They're not the ones coming over the ridge and being recognized for their own accomplishment. The last part of his quote, the experience part, can sometimes be true but not usually. If a person makes a big enough impression on a society, their experience won't die with them. Things will be affected by what they did after they die and others might have their same experiences.
Here is the post from Paige:
ReplyDeleteThe "wave" in society is ideas and society in general and how it changes over time. The society in 1984 has a new "wave". When the old wave(the last gereration)crashed, its ideas died with it. The people are not changing just the knowledge of the people. The generation that is left in 1984 that knows the past is the last of the wave but the past to the new generation is foreign. Once the last generations dies that lived before newspeak a new wave will begin.