Tuesday, April 21, 2009

Totalitarianism / Utopia / Movie April 21

What is your idea of a Utopia? What are the disadvantages and advantages to having a society similar to the one in the movie? What implications would it have on freedom? Safety? Would you want to have the ability to see the future? What elements of the movie do you see it today's society?

24 comments:

  1. I think a utopia is very bad because many freedoms are taken away. It is hard to appreciate a perfect society because there is no bad. The movie's society's disadvantages are no trials for murderers and people get locked up for not doing anything wrong because the cops stop it before it happens. The advantages are no murders except for two during the precrime time. It really limits people's freedoms. It helps society's safety a lot because no one is murdered. I would not want the ability to see the future because it would scare me. I would rather live the present not see the future. In today's society, the government has the power to track people's cell phone conversations of "Terrorists" and they have cameras everywhere. Many actions are on video and all over the internet and the government can access all of it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. My idea of Utopia would be a future where there is no crime, everyone is treated equally/fairly, there is no fatal diseases. To me the world would be an easy place to live in and life wouldn't be so hard. There are many disadvantages to a society similar to the one in movie. I think the movie's goverenment/precrime had a great idea but they took it too far. The precrime was great for preventing murders but the division was never 100% sure the crime would happen. This slight not knowing led to innocent people going to jail. I think the safety of the country went up but freedom become nonexistant. By automatically assuming a person commited a murder without it ever happening they are stripped of their rights as a citizen. Living in a world with a precrime system would be like living in a dictatorship. I would not want to be able to see the future. I wouldn't want that ability because with it comes huge responsibility that I don't think i could handle. I believe seeing the future would be extremely cool/beneficial but not worth all the problems it could cause. I dont really see our society resembling that in the movie but our society is on our way to possibly becoming that. Our society has had great technoligical discoveries that continue to get more advanced. Also with our society the government has become more watchful over citizens and is able to monitor them more closely just like the movie.

    ReplyDelete
  3. When I think of a utopia, I don't think of it in a good way. I think of a world where personal freedoms are limited, if not completely taken away.A utopia has many disadvantages, such as low diversity and no real representation in government. However, we saw many advantages of a utopia in "Minority Report". The murder rate was brought down to almost zero and people were more confident in their government's ability to keep them safe. If I had the choose to see the future like Agatha could, I would choose to ignore it. I would rather live in the moment than live in fear of the future. Even though "Minority Report" took place in 2054, some elements of a "utopian" society are present today. The government has the authority to tap our phone conversations if they think we are involved in criminal activities. The government can also track our bank records, phone records, and credit card purchases.

    ReplyDelete
  4. My idea of a utopia is a society where Jenna and Jessica are not around me. There would also be free ice cream on every street corner and large TVs on every wall. A utopia to me would not be a lifestyle, but more of the objects and fun activities around me. As well as the absence of some other aspects. The advantages to having a society like the one in the movie would be that there is less crime and there is more advanced technology. The disadvantages though, would be that if by some chance you want to kill someone (Jenna or Jessica), you would be tracked down and stopped before you could do so. Peoples' freedoms would not really be taken away because the only freedom is the freedom to commit murder, but people would be much more safe. I would not like to be able to see the future. I feel like if I did, I would be forced to actually do stuff... Like tell people that they were going to die, or notify police. Also, I like not knowing what is going to happen to me later. The aspects of the movie that I see in today's society are political, high up scandals as well as S.W.A.T.ish police forces. Also, they've got some pretty nice TVs...

    ReplyDelete
  5. My idea of a Utopia would be a safe world in which most people got along, there was no major conflicts between countries, and there were no major crimes, that general idea. But another thing added to that Utopia would be a controlled population. A controlled population would be necessary baecause if everyone was safe and happy, the population would skyrocket, resources would be used up, food and shelter would be scarce, and new problems would arise socially. Advantages to having a society like the one in the movie would be ,obviously, no murders. Ther would also be advances in society that makes health, technology and many other things better. Disadvantages to having a society like that would be possibly destroyed morals, no sense of what a Utopia is or isn't, and the possibiliy of a precog having an incorrect prevision. I think there would be no implications on safety, having precrime would increase safety. Even if a murder hadn't happened yet, it undoubtedly would've happend according to the precogs. It would definitly have implications on freedom though, considering the police might barge into someones house at seemingly anytime. I don't think Iwould want to see the total future, maybe a little piece of it though, something that is not really important. The reason for thatt is because it would just kind of be like a spoiled movie if I saw my whole detailed future. But, if I saw only little pieces, that would be okay because they would most likely be just unimportant things im wondering about. Elements in the movie that I see in today's society is the lessened privacy of someone's house. In the movie, they randomly barge into someone's personal house while in real life, the government now can listen to your phone calls.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I don't believe that any kind of true utopia is possible. A true utopia would have unlimited freedom in any situation, but this is not an acceptable solution to any problems of a non-utopian community. For example, true freedom is the right to do whatever you please, and that would include murder, drug use, etc. And with murder, you cut off the freedom of your victim to live, leaving true and total freedom as only a poor vision for society. In the movie The Minority Report, the government takes the right to decide to murder someone away and this gives most the freedom to live, except for the precogs, who have to live in a chamber watching murders over and over before they even happen. I find the ability to see the future almost disgusting; I would not want to have no will against seeing vicious murders all day and all night. This system is similar to today's government's attempts to reduce the murder rate by placing cameras in public places, invading citizens' personal rights. Also, the drug use in the movie is similar to today's drug issue, with government officials such as police officers using illegal substances.
    (btw kevin, you had 3 fatal errors in that paragraph)

    ReplyDelete
  7. I think a utopia would be a place where everything, such as politics and society, are perfect. There would be peace and no war. I always think of utopia to have a negative connotation because one is not attainable and in order for everything to be perfect, the government would require more involvement in citizens' everyday life, which is a nagative aspect. As great as it would be to have the lack of war, that would never happen because there will always be two groups in conflict somewhere, no matter the reason. The disadvantages that the movie's society had included to government knowing where any one person was at one time and many eye ID checks. In addition, those who "committed" murder had no right to a trial and were immediately locked up. The positive side of the movie's society was that with Precrime, the world was safer and none were subject to murder. Precime reduces ultimately freedoms if they can see the future, but it does keep the world safer. I would not want the ability to see the future because each person has a destiny that ought not be interfered with to keep that natural order of the world. Elements of the movie's society can be found in the Patriot Act, where the government has increased "rights" and "responsibilities" to search people's private lives.

    ReplyDelete
  8. My idea of a utopia would be a perfect world where everyone would get along and be happy most of the time and there would be no major conflicts, such as war. I do not think that having utopia is possible because I don't think it's possible for everyone to coexist together peacefully. The movie's society had several advantages and disadvantages. Because of precrime, murders were no longer commited because they were stopped before they could happen, but they were arresting innocent people who hadn't done anything wrong yet. We found out later in the movie that what the precogs saw might not come true because there were Minority Reports that showed an alternate future. Some of the people who had been arrested by Precrime might have changed their minds and wouldn't have done anything wrong, but they were never given the chance to decide. Precrime took away people's freedom by arresing them before they had done anything wrong. Precrime kept people safe, but may have also arrested innocent people who, if given the chance, may have made the right decision.

    ReplyDelete
  9. My idea of a utopia would be a place where the government would be uncorrupted, positions of authority would always be filled by the right people, poverty would be nonexistent, there would be no crime, and there would be worldwide peace. Unfortunately, this type of a world will never exist because of human nature. In Minority Report, the advantage was that there was no murder, but the disadvantage was that they could have been putting away innocent people. A better alternative to what they were doing, I think, would have been to just warn the perpetrator about what he/she had been predestined to do. Since almost of the murders were not planned, this would probably prevent most murders from happening. However, this does not solve the problem of the unfair treatment of the precogs, so I think precrime was rightfully abandoned. Precrime wouldn't really limit freedom, because I don't think that a freedom to kill someone is a human right. It would increase safety because of its lowered murder rate. I personally wouldn't want the ability to see into the future. It would just confuse things and mess up the natural progression of life. The biggest thing that I see in today's life from the movie is the little earpiece phone that I'm sure seemed very futuristic when the movie came out a few years ago. Today we have bluetooth headsets which are basically the same thing.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I do not like Utopia; I think it is hard to know where you live is good if you have never experienced bad. I think life would be too easy and there wouldn't be any challenge in life. People who rely on God during tough times would not rely on God as much because everything in their life would be perfect. In prime crime they were arresting potentially innocent people. The "murders" that the prime crime arrested could have had alternative futures but they would never know that. In some ways Utopia is being deprived of its freedom. I also think it is wrong to use the precogs to tell the future murders. I feel like the precogs are being deprived of their lives and not being treated like humans. I think this society could last for a short period of time but there is no such thing as perfect. I really enjoyed the movie though. I would not want to see the future because then i would just be paranoid about when I was going to die.

    ReplyDelete
  11. My idea of a utopian society would basically be a society with no poverty, starvation, crime, war, or murder. But I think that a utopian society would also include no excitement or unpredictability. I think unpredictability and not knowing what will happen next keeps life entertaining. I would not want the ability to see the future. There would be many advantages to a society similar to the one in the movie, with no murder. You would feel very safe living in a society where no one was murdered or harmed. I don't see too many disadvantages in living in that kind of a society. There would be a lack of privacy but that would only be a disadvantage if you were wanted by the police or the government. You would have pretty much the same freedoms in the movie's society as you would have in today's society, except if you were contemplating on murdering someone. There was an increase in safety in the movie's society, or at least an increase in the feeling of safety and security. In the movie's society, people could be located very easily with eye scanners. Although not as effective, with cell phone and credit card use, people in today's society can be tracked whenever they make a call, a purchase, or send a text.

    ReplyDelete
  12. My idea of a utopia would be where everyone was happy. Everyone would probably need to be moderately wealthy. There would also need to be some extent of freedom (although not necessarily free will). I think Brave New World is a pretty good utopia society even though its usually classified as a dystopia. In the society of Minority Report there are no murders (which is good) and the society's technology promotes many convenient measures. The bad stuff in Minority Report is that the government watches over the people too much (eye scans and stuff) and some people are accused of a crime they didn't even do. I think freedom is limited when the government heavily intervenes trying to promote the well being of the society. This society is safer though. I would not want to be able to see the future. The government wire tapped random telephone calls after 911 looking for terrorists, this is kinda similar to Minority Report and freedom, privacy, etc. The government also has expanded its role on the economy and for example owns 80% of AIG I believe. Minority Report's economy stills seems to be largely capitalistic although they don't delve too much into their economics so it's hard to tell for sure.

    ReplyDelete
  13. When I think of a utopia I think of everyone as equals, no wars or major conflicts, and what you might call an attempt to be a perfect society. The advantages to having a society similar to the movie is that there was rarely, if any crime anymore because the government would have already arrested the about-to-be murderer. Disadvantages are the there can be a minority report, meaning that there can be an alternate future besides what the precogs see as the future. Freedom will still be present, but not equal to the freedoms we have today. People then didn't have the freedom to choose their future, instead they could be arrested for the perceived future just like John's, but he chose not to kill. With the government catching all of the even possible killers in their society, the safety skyrocketed. If I could be a precog, or choose to see the future I wouldn't. I would not want to see murders all the time, and the precogs didn't have any freedoms, they weren't allowed to do anything other than just lay there in half sleep watching murders over and over. That is not a life I would like to choose for myself. Elements from the movie that are in today's society are that the government can track you through cameras, cell phones, and credit cards.

    ReplyDelete
  14. My idea of a "Utopia" is that everyone would be very tranquil and calm. No crimes would be committed and there would be no world problems. An advantage would be that everyone seems to be content with their lives. However, a disadvantage would be that the government would mist likely have the greatest influence on the citizens' actions. There would be less freedom and safety found in the society. I would not want to see the future. I would prefer to not know how I die, or who I marry or any other action; I would prefer to live my life as a spontaneous journey. A movie element reflected in today's society is illegal drug selling. John is addicted to an illegal drug that he buys off of a street seller. We see the exchange between money and drugs everyday, whether in a pharmacy or in a dark alley by a gas station. Another element seen in Minority Report is the power of the government. More and more, they are taking control over our lives. In the film, the PreCrime system not only catches the murderer, but it gives insight into the person’s house. Today, people are still being watched by "Big Brother" as well as other political figures.
    ~Greggles

    ReplyDelete
  15. My idea of a Utopian society is one where everything is "perfect." There would be no menial labor, disease, crime, inadequacy, or any form of hostility. Everyone would ascend in life according to the fruits of their labor, so to speak. All of the "Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse" would be gone and forgotten.

    As for the society in "Minority Report," precrime stood more to hinder than help, I think. Ideally, precrime would have allowed for a safe lifestyle that had no *serious* crime. Instead, the seemingly-good implications of precrime, a long with the retinal scanning and other devices, gave way to a sense of "Big brother." I'm surprised paranoia was not more rampant. As for similarities to our society, their economy does seem to remain capitalistic, and the social structure remains largely the same. They just traded a sense of freedom for safety.

    I would like to be able to see the future, but only selectively. I'd pass if it meant seeing murders in my dreams (with being helpless to stop them).

    ReplyDelete
  16. My idea of a utopia would be a world where everything is essentially perfect and there would be nothing wrong with the system like in the movie.All would be at peace. no crime, no wars, but not like the hippie peace. just tranquility in a way. Some advantages in having a society like one in the movie would be the fact that there was no murder. But also because of the precrime, people spent more and more time trying to find ways around getting caught like they did in teh 20's with prohibition. Because of the risk they would get caught, they were trying to still get away with it and it would make trying to commit those crimes more fun. But if you had a society like that, freedom would be limited and if there was any it would be very restricted. People couldn't even think about murdering someone withou the precogs seeing it. you had no freedom to think about waht you like. Saftey would go up substantially though. The citizens would be so much more safe and protected than they would be if precrime didnt exist. If i had the choice, iwould not want to see the future. Because if i did see it and didnt like it, i would be unhappy for most of my life knowing i would just end up unhappy anyways. Or if i knew who was supposed to marry, i would spend my lfe looking for him and then end up missing him at some point. Or if you knew how you were going to die, you would try everyting in our power to avoid that. Yo would go to extreme measures to stay away from where you are going t die.

    ReplyDelete
  17. My idea of a utopia is a place where there is no crime and everyone is under a microscope. Everyone is exactly the same and no one is different. I think living here would be easy and care free. You wouldn't really have to worry about fitting in or the dangers of being robed or murdered. As for "Minority Report" the precrime unit is effective but some people may not actually go through with it. So someone innocent is sent away. I feel like I wouldn't want to live in a world like that. I wouldn't want to know the future, I wouldn't want to see how I die or who I marry like Greg said. The precrime system had flaws and I wouldn't be able to trust that type of unit.

    ReplyDelete
  18. My personal idea of a utopia is a place where you have little to nothing to truly worry about. I believe some chaos is neccesary for people to remain mentally sound and happy. Can you really know good if there is not bad? After all, these terms are subjective. One of the advantages to living in a society like the one in the movie is that you would never have to worry if you'd make it to bed alive that night. but is the sacrifice to freedom really worth it? As Benjamin Franklin said "They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." Everywhere they went, the government and possibly worse, the corporations, knew the details of their every action, as shown by the talking advertisements. Would you really want someone knowing exactly what you do every second of every day, in exchange for a little saftey? I personally would like to see the future, but only on a selective, at will basis. I think it would be interesting to see how the future changes with the actions you take. I find as time goes by, there are more and more of the elements of the movie present in our society, such as the cameras in England, the NSA and AT&T wiretapping, the targeted ads from google, the Anti-Counterfiting Trade Agreement, and various other laws that remore our freedoms in the name of "National Security"

    ReplyDelete
  19. my idea of a utopea would be where everyone is taken care of. Individial needs are met and everyone lives in florida. Florida is the place to live because no one can get mad there. its not allowed. The advantages to having a perfect society would be the security and the crime managment. The bad things about the government controlling society is the room for human error just like in the movie. Security would be high and people would feel safe due to the fact that the government is taking care of them. Freedom would be there but it would not be actually "free" due to the fact that the government is controlling what you can or can not do. I would not want to see the future because i would not want to see things happen in the future i did not like and then try to alter them which would affect many people. Today government stills watches us to see if they can catch any sorts of crime going on and the drug bussiness is still big today just like in the movie.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Well, firstly, I'd like to review the dictionary definition of utopia: An imagined place or state of things in which everything is perfect. Would a utopia give people all the rights they need? Yes. A utopia is perfect. We would have freedom as well as safety. Everyone would have everything they want, all the time. There would be no crime and no disease. That's what the definition implies. I don't think there would be any disadvantages to a real Utopia, but the world of Minority Report is able to be manipulated by those with important positions and a lot of power.

    I think the ability to sense the future would be extremely detrimental to society. There would be wars unlike any we have ever experienced over those who could view the future, and no one's actions would be private anymore. To compare Minority Report to our world, fingerprints are the closest things to the futuristic eye-scanners.

    ReplyDelete
  21. My idea of a utopia is a society where drugs and violence, and famine don't exist. There are the adrenaline rushes and activities, without the dangers that come along with them. In the movie there was the advantage of being able to stop murder, however, murder is only a small part of a much larger problem. Drugs, theft, asault, all parts of the much larger problem of crime. I think that there would be less privacy, but only for certain people as Emily said. The people who are doing things they shouldnt necessarily be doing anyways would have a lack of privact, not as much for everyone else though. The increase in safety would be much more beneficial than the lack of privacy, in my oppinion. Personally, I would not want to be able to see the future simply because as Jessica said, it brings to much responsibility along with it. The society in the movie is largely the same as ours, there is still theft, drugs, political corruption. Not to mention the governments abilities to track credit cards, cell phones etc.

    ReplyDelete
  22. My idea of a utopia is, like every else's, a perfect society; no negative aspects present anywhere. The idea of one is utterly impossible, however, because everyone's view of perfection and happiness is different. The disadvantages to having a society likewise to the one in the movie is that you would have to sacrifice many personal freedoms, like privacy, to gain safety. You would also have to gain a new sense of equality and justice, due to the fact that criminals are only being punished for possible future crimes. The advantages, of course, would be the huge increase in personal safety from future attacks on one's life. They simply wouldn't happen due to the precog's ability to see future murders. I would not want to be able to see the future. If you were able to see the future, you would conform all your daily actions to trying to avoid negative outcomes, but in reality, you are simply creating the circumstances to make the future take place as is anyway. Instead of knowing the future and not being able to escape it, I would simply want to live my life blind of tomorrow: only live for today (in the sense related to future-sight). The elements I see in today's society that mirror the movie's are the fact that we have personal identification systems: social security and such. There are also credit cards and cell phones to be tracked on and with. The same principle exists here: we are trading some personal privacy/ freedom for an amount of safety.

    ReplyDelete
  23. My idea of utopia is a perfect society; no crime, wars or anything of that matter. Even though this is basically impossible it would still be nice. I think there would be more disadvantages than advantages to having a society just like the movies. Like other people said it would take away our freedom. It would really only be good for stopping murder. And i would not want to be able to the the future. This is because if i saw something i didn't want to happen i would probably try to change it and then everything would go wrong. Kind of like on the show "That's So Raven".

    ReplyDelete